Custom structure/type that can be used with switch()

Question

One of my projects has a value type/struct that represents a custom identifier string for a video format. In this case, it's going to contain a content type string, but that can vary.

I've used a struct so it can be strongly type when it's passed around, and perform some sanity checks on the initial string value. The actual string value could be anything and provided by external plugins libraries so a numeric enum doesn't apply.

public struct VideoFormat {
    private string contentType;

    public VideoFormat(string contentType) {
        this.contentType = contentType;
    }

    public string ContentType {
        get { return this.contentType; }
    }

    public override string ToString() {
        return this.contentType;
    }

    // various static methods for implicit conversion to/from strings, and comparisons
}

As there are a few very common formats, I've exposed these as static read only fields with default values.

public static readonly VideoFormat Unknown = new VideoFormat(string.Empty);
public static readonly VideoFormat JPEG = new VideoFormat("image/jpeg");
public static readonly VideoFormat H264 = new VideoFormat("video/h264");

This seems to work on most cases except a switch block where it says the value has to be a constant. Is there any way I can make use of this type and the static values directly in a switch block without switching on the internal member or the .ToString() override?

Is there a better overall method to do this without using a design time specified enum with numeric values or plain string constants?

Goldfarb

Why not use else if statement instead of a switch statement? – Orvieto

@Orvieto if ... else is an option, but I've historically preferred switch where the conditions are multiple and "fixed" – Goldfarb

I've removed the bit asking about the best method to expose common values and moved it to this question. – Goldfarb

Answer 1

UPDATE: This answer is no longer entirely accurate due to new rules for switch statements in C# 7. See the C# 7 documentation for details.

---

Is there any way I can make use of this type and the static values directly in a switch block

No. The governing type of a switch statement must be one of sbyte, byte, short, ushort, int, uint, long, ulong, char, bool, any enum, the nullable value types of any of those, or string. And the constants used in the case labels must be compile time constants compatible with the governing type.

Financial

Answer 2

Actually it might be better to refactor the code so that you don't have to use switch statements at all. Although the construction itself is not an anti-pattern, but it is commonly accepted practice to use polymorphism instead. Here is another discussion of the ways to get rid of switch.

Bribery

Answer 3

It seems to me that all the possible videoformats you're working with could be a classic example for using enumerations. I really don't see a problem to extend your enumeration with new values when some other formats will be added. Yes, the important thing we need to be sure that any VideoFormat used in the program should fit the enumeration. But possibly it won't be a disadvantage.

Firm

Formats can be added and handled outside the core library by plugins. I don't want to tie it to having X fixed formats. – Goldfarb

Then maybe you can use a dictionary? – Firm

How would a dictionary help? It's just a string identifier to go with the frame data. – Goldfarb