How to pass a predicate as parameter c#

Question

How can I pass a predicate into a method but also have it work if no predicate is passed? I thought maybe something like this, but it doesn't seem to be correct.

private bool NoFilter() { return true; }

private List<thing> GetItems(Predicate<thing> filter = new Predicate<thing>(NoFilter))
{
    return rawList.Where(filter).ToList();
}

Clyte

You are asking for default value, right? Otherwise, define NoFilter as Predicate<things> and pass it. – Soulier

Create an overload GetItems() { return GetItems(NoFilter); } – Reach

You can have a default value of null and you'd have to check for that in your code. Alternatively you could overload the method with a second one that doesn't take a predicate. – Dasher

@Servy May be is not a dupplicate and the OP have an issue passing a delegate as parameter ? – Gratulant

You default value must be resolved at compile time. new Predicate<thing>(NoFIlter) is evaluated at run time because of the constructor there so it will not work however you put it. – Ariana

@BRAHIMKamel That's not what their question is asking. Their question is asking how to ensure that the parameter is optional and that NoFilter is used when no parameter is provided. They're not asking how to pass a normal delegate as a parameter to a method. – Karlotte

@Ariana A default value needs to be a constant. new Predicate<thing>(NoFIlter) is resolved entirely at compile time, but it's simply not specified in the specs as a compile time constant. – Karlotte

@Karlotte it never occurred to me that new Predicate<thing>(NoFilter) is resolved when the code is compiling. Now that you say it I can see how. Thanks – Ariana

@Joel Coehoorn How is the question not a duplicate? It's asking literally exactly the same thing as the duplicate question. – Karlotte

@Karlotte Actually I was, as the title says, asking how to pass a predicate as a parameter. I tossed in the optional bit to see how a null predicate was handled as well (which was addressed nicely in the accepted answer). – Clyte

@Clyte And that's just a duplicate of an answer in the question it was closed as a duplicate of. You're simply demonstrating that the question was unquestionably a duplicate. – Karlotte

Just because two questions have the same answer it doesn't mean they are the same. Example of two questions with the same answer. What is 2 + 2 and What it is 2 * 2? Same answer, two different questions. My question was about passing predicates, not about a compile time constant error. – Clyte

Answer 1

private List<thing> GetItems(Func<thing, bool> filter = null)
{
    return rawList.Where(filter ?? (s => true)).ToList();
}

In this expression s => true is the fallback filter which is evaluated if the argument filter is null. It just takes each entry of the list (as s) and returns true.

Corwun

Getting an error like this when I implement Cannot convert from System.Predicate<thing> to System.LinQ.Expressions.Expression<SystemFunc<thing,bool>> – Clyte

Try Func<Thing, bool> instead of Predicate<Thing> – Corwun

For no warning use: Func<thing, bool>? filter = null – Evyn

Answer 2

There are two parts to this.

First, you need to adjust the NoFilter() function to be compatible with Predicate<T>. Notice the latter is generic, but the former is not. Make NoFilter() look like this:

private bool NoFilter<T>(T item) { return true; }

I know you never use the generic type argument, but it's necessary to make this compatible with your predicate signature.

For fun, you could also define NoFilter this way:

private Predicate<T> NoFilter = x => true;

Now the second part: we can look at using the new generic method as the default argument for GetItems(). The trick here is you can only use constants. While NoFilter() will never change, from the compiler's view that's not quite the same things a a formal constant. In fact, there is only one possible constant you can use for this: null. That means your method signature must look like this:

private List<thing> GetItems(Predicate<thing> filter = null)

Then you can check for null at the beginning of your function and replace it with NoFilter:

private List<thing> GetItems(Predicate<thing> filter = null)
{
    if (filter == null) filter = NoFilter;
    return rawList.Where(filter).ToList();
}

And if you also do want to explicitly pass this to the method when calling it, that would look like this:

var result = GetItems(NoFilter);

That should fully answer the original question, but I don't want to stop here. Let's look deeper.

Since you need the if condition anyway now, at this point I would tend to remove the NoFilter<T>() method entirely, and just do this:

private IEnumerable<thing> GetItems(Predicate<thing> filter = null)
{
    if (filter == null) return rawList;
    return rawList.Where(filter);
}

Note that I also changed the return type and removed the ToList() call at the end. If you find yourself calling ToList() at the end of a function just to match a List<T> return type, it's almost always much better to change the method signature to return IEnumerable<T> instead. If you really need a list (and usually, you don't), you can always call ToList() after calling the function.

This change makes your method more useful, by giving you a more abstract type that will be more compatible with other interfaces, and it potentially sets you up for a significant performance bump, both in terms of lowered memory use and in terms of lazy evaluation.

One final addition here is, if you do pare down to just IEnumerable, we can see now this method does not really provide much value at all beyond the base rawItems field. You might look at converting to a property, like this:

public IEnumerable<T> Items {get {return rawList;}}

This still allows the consumer of your type use a predicate (or not) if they want via the existing .Where() method, while also continuing to hide the underlying raw data (you can't directly just call .Add() etc on this).

Rourke

i get an error on the after filter passed into the .Where().. assuming rawList is a list of String objects... cannot convert System.Predicate<String> to System.Func<string, bool> .. can't be the only one?? – Extrapolate

A Predicate<X> is the same thing as a Func<X, bool>. It should be convertible, or perhaps an overload or reference is missing. Otherwise, it's a simple change. – Rourke

hmm... i feel there is something fundamental i'm missing here, can't even figure out what the shape of the thing i need to pass in to GetItems() should be... think i will open a new q! – Extrapolate