Foreign Key add fails in MySQL with Error Code 1005, number 150

Question

So I'm attempting to add a new foreign key to one of my tables as such:

 ALTER TABLE `UserTransactions`.`ExpenseBackTransactions` 
   ADD CONSTRAINT `FK_EBTx_CustomAccountID`
   FOREIGN KEY (`CustomAccountID` )
   REFERENCES `UserTransactions`.`CustomAccounts` (`CustomAccountID`)
   ON DELETE NO ACTION
   ON UPDATE NO ACTION,
   ADD INDEX `FK_EBTx_CustomAccountID` (`CustomAccountID` ASC) ;

and I keep getting the following error:

Error Code: 1005
Can't create table './UserTransactions/#sql-187a_29.frm' (errno: 150)

I've done quite a bit of changes in the past to this and other tables, and this is the first time I've run into this issue. Any ideas what is causing it?

UPDATE

My SHOW INNODB STATUS error:

------------------------
LATEST FOREIGN KEY ERROR
------------------------
110525 15:56:36 Error in foreign key constraint of table UserTransactions/#sql-187a_2c:

  FOREIGN KEY (`CustomAccountID` )
  REFERENCES `UserTransactions`.`CustomAccounts` (`CustomAccountID` )
  ON DELETE NO ACTION
  ON UPDATE NO ACTION
, ADD INDEX `FK_EBTx_CustomAccountID` (`CustomAccountID` ASC):
Cannot resolve table name close to:
 (`CustomAccountID` )
  ON DELETE NO ACTION
  ON UPDATE NO ACTION
, ADD INDEX `FK_EBTx_CustomAccountID` (`CustomAccountID` ASC)

Obsequious

What does SHOW INNODB STATUS say? Do both columns have the same datatype (and length?)? Is there already another key with that name in the database somewhere? – Cronin

FOREIGN KEY is only supported by InnoDB dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.5/en/… . check if this is causing the problem. – Radiopaque

@Ibrahim: myisam silently ignores foreign key specifications without error. – Janniejanos

Answer 1

There's a nice checklist here.

Below is a running list of known causes that people have reported for the dreaded errno 150:

1. The two key fields type and/or size is not an exact match. For example, if one is INT(10) the key field needs to be INT(10) as well and not INT(11) or TINYINT. You may want to confirm the field size using SHOW CREATE TABLE because Query Browser will sometimes visually show just INTEGER for both INT(10) and INT(11). You should also check that one is not SIGNED and the other is UNSIGNED. They both need to be exactly the same. (More about signed vs unsigned here).
2. One of the key field that you are trying to reference does not have an index and/or is not a primary key. If one of the fields in the relationship is not a primary key, you must create an index for that field. (thanks to Venkatesh and Erichero and Terminally Incoherent for this tip)
3. The foreign key name is a duplicate of an already existing key. Check that the name of your foreign key is unique within your database. Just add a few random characters to the end of your key name to test for this. (Thanks to Niels for this tip)
4. One or both of your tables is a MyISAM table. In order to use foreign keys, the tables must both be InnoDB. (Actually, if both tables are MyISAM then you won’t get an error message – it just won’t create the key.) In Query Browser, you can specify the table type.
5. You have specified a cascade ON DELETE SET NULL, but the relevant key field is set to NOT NULL. You can fix this by either changing your cascade or setting the field to allow NULL values. (Thanks to Sammy and J Jammin)
6. Make sure that the Charset and Collate options are the same both at the table level as well as individual field level for the key columns. (Thanks to FRR for this tip)
7. You have a default value (ie default=0) on your foreign key column (Thanks to Omar for the tip)
8. One of the fields in the relationship is part of a combination (composite) key and does not have its own individual index. Even though the field has an index as part of the composite key, you must create a separate index for only that key field in order to use it in a constraint. (Thanks to Alex for this tip)
9. You have a syntax error in your ALTER statement or you have mistyped one of the field names in the relationship (Thanks to Christian & Mateo for the tip)
10. The name of your foreign key exceeds the max length of 64 chars. (Thanks to Nyleta for the tip)

Cronin

Turns out that it was a table that got accidentally created as a MyISAM instead of a InnoDB. A very interesting way of ID-10-T error exposing itself. – Obsequious

I would have been searching for hours without that checklist... Seems like the other table was created when the MySQL installation did not yet support InnoDB. – Pasha

11. the table or column exists you are trying to reference with the foreign key. It is a simple thing that sometimes people like me forget – Discoid

Answer 2

In my experience, the errno: 150 usually indicates that the data types of the FOREIGN KEY column in the key table and relating table are not identical. Make sure that CustomAccounts.CustomAccountID and ExpenseBackTransactions.CustomAccountIDare the exact same type, including UNSIGNED if it applies.

If that doesn't help, please post the SHOW CREATE TABLE ExpenseBackTransactions; and SHOW CREATE TABLE CustomAccounts;

Ermaermanno

you mean show create table, right? but otherwise, yes, spot on. it's most likely a field type mis-match between the two tables. – Janniejanos

Answer 3

Catch 22. Foreign keys need indexes. MySQL doesn't order this query so that the index exists at the time it does it foreign key checks. Thus, first create the index, then add the foreign key in 2 separate queries.

Sarcenet

Tried that, thinking that was what the error was, but it ended up not working with just the ADD CONSTRAINT command after the ADD INDEX command was run. – Obsequious

This was true on older MySQL versions, but not anymore on any recent 5.x series. – Janniejanos