Android service onCreate is called multiple times without calling onDestroy

Question

In my app, I use a service to communicate with our server. The Service spawns several message queue threads to deal with tasks with different priorities.

This model has been used for about one year without big issues. However, recently, I found some time the onCreate of my service class are called multiple times. onDestroy is never called between two onCreate calls. Therefore, I did not get chance to kill existing threads. Once this behavior happens, the service has duplicate threads inside.

The only thing I have changed is to run the service as foreground service is a user signs in the app. I am wondering whether foreground service cause the problem.

Any ideas?

Winterkill

same problem call stopSelf() service then after automatically call onCreate() multiple time call onCreate() method – Colic

Answer 1

I had the same problem when my service used the same process with activities(default). but no more problems when I made my service use another process. I edited my AndroidManifest.xml like below... (added android:process attribute)

<service android:name="kr.co.pkbio.binoo.CacheFileManagerService" android:process=":kr.co.pkbio.binoo.service"/>
<service android:name="kr.co.pkbio.binoo.ActivityStackManagerService" android:process=":kr.co.pkbio.binoo.service"/>

see http://developer.android.com/guide/topics/manifest/service-element.html for information.

Tensiometer

I have a service that runs in a different process but still has this problem occasionally. – Thereabout

Answer 2

I had exactly the same problem when I was dealing with a bluetooth service (the problem occurred during the development). When I disconnected my device and killed the ADB it didn't happen again and onCreate was called only once. I assume it is some bug because it happens from time to time. But maybe you have a slightly different problem...

Zeuxis

Answer 3

This might become useful to someone. I had this same issue when storing a map through a bundle in a onSaveInstanceState method in one of my activities. I believe because the map contained references to objects that were being used in other parts of the app (one of them was my service) every time I left said activity, my service would start all over again.

I'm guessing this is android OS shenanigans.

Fields

How did you solve this? I'm having the same problem. When I leave the main app, my service gets recreated. – Chink