CAREFUL with placing 'implementation' in the Domain Layer.
Your domain code doesn't have dependencies. So, you are in trouble if you need to have complex factories.
For example:
// DOMAIN LAYER
public interface IAggregateFactory<TAgg, in TInput>
{
Task<TAgg> CreateAsync(TInput input);
}
public class AvailabilityFactoryParameters
{
public string SomeInputParameter { get; set; }
public string ZipCode { get; set; }
}
// INFRASTRUCTURE/APPLICATION LAYER
public class AvailabilityFactory : IAggregateFactory<GamePredictorAggregate,
GamePredictorFactoryParameters>
{
private readonly HttpClient _httpClient;
public AvailabilityFactory(IHttpClientFactory factory)
{
_httpClient = factory.CreateClient("weatherApi");
}
public async Task<GamePredictorAggregate> CreateAsync(GamePredictorFactoryParameters input)
{
var weather = await _httpClient.GetFromJsonAsync<WeatherDto>($"/weather/{input.ZipCode}");
return new GamePredictorAggregate(weather.CurrentTemperature, input.SomeInputParameter);
}
}
public class WeatherDto
{
public double CurrentTemperature { get; set; }
}
As you can see, now you have a myriad of objects and dependencies available to enrich your factory experience.
So, when you use it in your Application Service, it is easy...
public class GamePredictionService : ApplicationService
{
private readonly IAggregateFactory<GamePredictorAggregate, GamePredictorFactoryParameters> _factory;
public GamePredictionService(IAggregateFactory<GamePredictorAggregate, GamePredictorFactoryParameters> factory)
{
_factory = factory;
}
public async Task CreateNewPredictor(string zipCode, int someOtherParamater)
{
var input = new GamePredictorFactoryParameters();
input.ZipCode = zipCode;
input.SomeInputParameter = someOtherParamater;
var aggregate = await _factory.CreateAsync(input);
// Do your biz operations
// Persist using repository
}
}
Now your application service doesn't need to worry about the internals, and your domain objects need to understand how the factory gives them 'birth.'
Summary: Having your implementation in the Domain layer makes only sense if your factory only needs primitive types and nothing else. In cases where you may need to gather data from external services or other application services' DTOs, you want to move the implementation outside.
The only 'drawback' is that you need to 'inject' the factory into your application service, but that's not a big deal.
I hope this answer helps to clarify 'where to place Factories.'
