Java Authenticator on a per connection basis?

Question

I'm building an Eclipse plugin that talks to a REST interface which uses Basic Authentication. When the authentication fails I would like to popup my plugin's settings dialog and retry. Normally I could use the static Authenticator.setDefault() to setup an authenticator for all HttpURLConnection's for this, but since I am writing a plugin I don't want to overwrite Eclipse's default Authenticator (org.eclipse.ui.internal.net.auth);

I thought of setting my custom Authenticator before loading and putting Eclipse's default back afterwards, but I imagine this will cause all sorts of race issues with multithreading so I quickly lost that notion.

Google searches yield all sorts of results basically telling me it's not possible:

The Java URLConnection API should have a setAuthenticator(Authenticator) method for making it easier to use this class in multi-threaded context where authentication is required.

Source

If applications contains few third party plugins and each plugin use its own Authenticator what we should do? Each invocation of "Authenticator.setDefault()" method rewrite previously defined Authenticator...

Source

Are there any different approaches that might help me overcome this issue?

Mcbryde

+1 I have the same problem. Very annoying! – Gabriellegabrielli

Answer 1

If it is not possible with HttpURLConnection I would suggest using the httpclient library from Apache.

A quick example:

HttpClient client = new HttpClient();
client.getState().setCredentials(AuthScope.ANY, new UsernamePasswordCredentials("test","test"));
GetMethod getMethod = new GetMethod("http://www.example.com/mylogin");
client.executeMethod(getMethod);
System.out.println(getMethod.getResponseBodyAsString());

Ammieammine

yeah The apache commoms http client is what i had settled on using if this issue with the JRE default HttpURLConnection is onovercomeable. Thanks for the answer though! – Mcbryde

In the end opting for a 3rd party Http class was the only viable solution, so i'll accept your answer. – Mcbryde

Answer 2

Another approach would be to perform the basic authentication yourself on the connection.

    final byte[] encodedBytes = Base64.encodeData((username + ':' + new String(password)).getBytes("iso-8859-1"));
    final String encoded = new String(encodedBytes, "iso-8859-1");

    connection.setRequestProperty("Authorization", "Basic " + encoded);

This would also have the advantage of not requiring an unauthenticated request to receive a 401 before providing the credential on a subsequent request. Similar behavior can be leveraged in the apache http-client by requesting preemptive authentication.

Goings

Thanks a LOT! You saved my day. Authenticator.setDefault is a complete CRIME... – West