Ansible: [WARNING]: Found both group and host with same name

Question

Using the ec2.py inventory script to query against my EC2 instances. I keep getting the following warning signs. How can i suppress them by fixing what's causing the issue?

[WARNING]: Found both group and host with same name: nex-1.XYZ.net
[WARNING]: Found both group and host with same name: admin-1.XYZ.net
[WARNING]: Found both group and host with same name: jenkinsmaster-1.XYZ.net

Martinsen

More here on this feature here: github.com/ansible/ansible/pull/22519 – Denman

Answer 1

Spotting the reuse of the same name as host and group is easy :

[webserver]
webserver

But it might be trickier because sometimes it's just you have forgotten to add the :children in your group definition

This definition will rise a Warning :

[webservers]               # <-- 'webservers' is a group
web1
web2

[agent_x]
webservers                 # <-- 'webservers' is a host 

While this one won't :

[webservers]               # <-- 'webservers' is a group
web1
web2

[agent_x:children]
webservers                 # <-- 'webservers' is a group

Quote from ansible 2.4 documentation https://github.com/ansible/ansible/blob/stable-2.4/docs/docsite/rst/intro_inventory.rst#groups-of-groups-and-group-variables

It is also possible to make groups of groups using the :children suffix in INI or the children: entry in YAML

Meaning you have to be explicit whether the group will list hosts or groups.

Gunplay

Answer 2

It happens because you probably have the same names into your inventory, for example this follow inventory:

[webserver]
webserver
webserver1

We have one host called webserver and the same name into group, could be a problem when you want to do something to group webserver don't you think?

If it happens when you use Dynamic Inventory like ec2.py the name probably is duplicated into your AWS envinronment, I recommend you change this.

Selfexpression

Answer 3

Solved this problem in a very simple way: i forgot to add :children after my groupname

Sieve