How do you replace endorsed directory in Java 9?

Question

In Java 8 and prior there exists the mechanism to use an endorsed directory(java.endorsed.dirs), which is a collection of libraries which overrides JDK internal implementations.

How can I solve this in Java-9? As endorsed dirs where removed there?

Grandmamma

You don't, you use modules instead. Problems with endorsed and classpath is fixed with modules, becuase of several reasons. – Portray

Answer 1

In JDK 9, you can use upgradeable modules or put the JAR files on the classpath.

The Java 9 migration guide states:

The java.endorsed.dirs system property and the lib/endorsed directory are no longer present. The javac compiler and java launcher will exit if either one is detected.

You would end up finding the error if any of these exists as :

<JAVA_HOME>/lib/endorsed is not supported. Endorsed standards and
standalone APIs in modular form will be supported via the concept of
upgradeable modules. Error: Could not create the Java Virtual Machine.
Error: A fatal exception has occurred. Program will exit.

---

These endorsed-standards override mechanism was removed to attain Modular Run-Time Images and would now use the modular image.

A modular image is composed of modules rather than JAR files. Going forward, endorsed standards and standalone APIs are supported in modular form only, via the concept of upgradeable modules.

Torero

Answer 2

This is a specific solution but can probably be generalized. On System Version: macOS 10.14.6 (18G3020) Kernel Version: Darwin 18.7.0 I have OpenJDK 64-Bit Server VM (build 13.0.2+8, mixed mode, sharing) and java_ee_sdk-8u1 installed.

I encountered this error when executing xjc:

[foo@bar bin 14:47:27] sudo ./xjc
-Djava.endorsed.dirs=./../modules/endorsed is not supported. Endorsed standards and standalone APIs
in modular form will be supported via the concept of upgradeable modules.
Error: Could not create the Java Virtual Machine.
Error: A fatal exception has occurred. Program will exit.enter code here

I edited the last line in ~/glassfish5/glassfish/bin/xjc to remove the -Djava.endorsed.dirs bit: BEFORE

exec "$JAVA" -Djava.endorsed.dirs="$AS_INSTALL_LIB/endorsed" -cp "$AS_INSTALL_LIB/webservices-osgi.jar:$AS_INSTALL_LIB/javax.xml.rpc-api.jar:$AS_INSTALL_LIB/jaxb-osgi.jar" com.sun.tools.xjc.Driver "$@"

AFTER

exec "$JAVA" -cp "$AS_INSTALL_LIB/webservices-osgi.jar:$AS_INSTALL_LIB/javax.xml.rpc-api.jar:$AS_INSTALL_LIB/jaxb-osgi.jar" com.sun.tools.xjc.Driver "$@"

After which ~/glassfish5/glassfish/bin/xjc worked as expected

Aloes

@IsanRodriguezTrimiño Hahaha!! me too!! – Bareback

Hahahaha, me too, Java goes Brrrrr now. – Comte

Answer 3

I also faced same issue, Java versions higher than 8 are not supported by Tomcat 9. Please check bin/catalina.sh for more information.

JAVA_ENDORSED_DIRS (Optional) Lists of of colon separated directories containing some jars in order to allow replacement of APIs created outside of the JCP (i.e. DOM and SAX from W3C). It can also be used to update the XML parser implementation. This is only supported for Java <= 8. Defaults to $CATALINA_HOME/endorsed.

Mccowyn

"Java versions higher than 8 are not supported by Tomcat 9" This is not true, look at the official site. It clearly says "8 and later". – Virginiavirginie

What is not supported after Java 8 is the switch -Djava.endorsed.dirs=.... It is not Tomcat that isn't supporting Java 9 and later. – Portray