I've worked with a few different languages such as Java, C#, and Objective-C.
In most languages, methods that don't require an instance of an object are called static methods. However, when it comes to Objective-C, some people get defensive when you call them static methods, and they expect you to call them class methods.
Why are they called class methods instead of static methods? What is the difference between a static method and a class method?
So my question is why are they called class methods instead of a static method? What is the difference between a static method and a class method?
From Wikipedia: Static methods neither require an instance of the class nor can they implicitly access the data (or this, self, Me, etc.) of such an instance.
This describes exactly what Objective-C's class methods are not.
An Objective-C class method very much requires an instance that is the target of the method invocation. That is, it requires an instance of the metaclass that describes the class object being invoked.
Unlike static methods, Objective-C's class methods can be inherited (which, in combination with having the aforementioned self, is exactly why many classes can share a single, simple, implementation of +alloc on NSObject without needing their own custom implementations) and invoking a class method goes through the exact same objc_msgSend* based dispatch mechanism as any other method call site.
Objective-C's class methods can be overridden across the class hierarchy and they can be swizzled. None of which is supported in languages that typically offer static methods in lieu of class methods.
The bottom line is that static methods and class methods are very different. While that difference is mostly transparent for day to day coding purposes, there are still situations where knowing how class methods work can save you a ton of unnecessary lines of code.
For example, you can't do this with static methods:
@interface AbstractClass:NSObject
+ factory;
@end
@implementation AbstractClass
+ factory
{
return [[[self alloc] init] autorelease];
}
@end
@interface Concrete1:AbstractClass
@end
@implementation Concrete1
@end
@interface Concrete2:AbstractClass
@end
@implementation Concrete2
@end
void foo() {
Concrete1 *c = [Concrete1 factory];
Concrete2 *d = [Concrete2 factory];
... etc ...
}
public. This answer is correct regarding ObjC but its wrong and misleading regarding the supposed distinction between 'class method' and 'static method'; there is no such distinction, other than in your head. Besides, you forgot to mention the only thing that might resemble a distinction: objC classes are themselves objects of metaclass type –
Horology Because it's dynamically bound, not static.
Because it's really a class object's instance method.
Objective-C class method is actually an object's class object's instance method.
It's hard to describe with text. See nice illustration here.
http://www.sealiesoftware.com/blog/archive/2009/04/14/objc_explain_Classes_and_metaclasses.html
Though class methods and static methods are in practice the same most of the time, they are different. With static methods the class is acting as a namespace qualifier. With class methods the class itself is an object and so class methods are to the class object exactly the same thing instance methods are to an instance; as a consequence you can do the following
@interface TestClass : NSObject
+ (void)classOrInstanceMethod;
- (void)classOrInstanceMethod;
@end
...
NSArray * arr = [NSArray arrayWithObjects:
[[[TestClass alloc] init] autorelease],
[TestClass class],
nil];
for( id obj in arr )
[obj classOrInstanceMethod];
which version of classOrInstanceMethod is called depends on whether obj is a class object or and instance. If you are familiar with the factory class pattern, this pattern is part of the Objective-C language.
This is purely a historical difference, mostly stemming from the fact that Objective-C was developed contemporaneously with C++, and before C++ or later languages like Java and C# had much influence. Objective-C was essentially a port of the Smalltalk object model to C, so its syntax and terminology don't necessarily seem as "C-like" as that used by C++. However, Objective-C was in no way bucking a trend by not using the term "static method", because that trend wasn't well-established back in 1983.
Class Method: Class methods in OOP are methods that are bound to a class rather than an instance of the class. They are defined within the class definition and are accessed using the class itself, rather than an instance of the class. @classmethod decorator is used to define a class method.
Whereas
Static Method: In OOPs, a static method is a method that belongs to a class rather than an instance of the class. It is associated with the class itself, rather than with specific objects created from the class. Static methods can be called directly on the class itself without the need to create an instance. Here, @staticmethod decorator is used.
Also, there is another method called instance method. You can read the differences here.
@classmethod or @staticmethod. The question is specifically asking about Objective-C. –
Rubellite © 2022 - 2024 — McMap. All rights reserved.
Classinstances (e.g.+[NSObject class]) which are themselves fully-fledged objects with methods of their own. – Armrest