What is the Dart "Expando" feature about, what does it do?

Question

Have been seeing the term "Expando" used recently with Dart. Sounds interesting. The API did not provide much of a clue to me.

An example or two could be most helpful!

(Not sure if this is related, but I am most anxious for a way to add methods (getters) and/or variables to a class. Hoping this might be a key to solving this problem. (hint: I am using the Nosuchmethod method now and want to be able to return the value of the unfound method.))

Thanks in advance,

_swarmii

Texas

Answer 1

Expandos allow you to associate objects to other objects. One very useful example of this is an HTML DOM element, which cannot itself be sub-classed. Let's make a top-level expando to add some functionality to an element - in this case a Function signature given in the typedef statement:

typedef CustomFunction(int foo, String bar);

Expando<CustomFunction> domFunctionExpando = new Expando<CustomFunction>();

Now to use it:

main(){
   // Assumes dart:html is imported
   final myElement = new DivElement();

   // Use the expando on our DOM element.
   domFunctionExpando[myElement] = someFunc;

   // Now that we've "attached" the function to our object,
   // we can call it like so:
   domFunctionExpando[myElement](42, 'expandos are cool');
}

void someFunc(int foo, String bar){
  print('Hello. $foo $bar');
}

Tippet

What is different between this and Map<Element, CustomFunction> ? – Epoch

@ZdeněkMlčoch An Expando doesn't prevent garbage collection of the keys! In this regard it could be compared to JavaScript's WeakMap. – Colonial

Answer 2

Just to clarify the difference between expando and maps: as reported in the groups, expando has weak references.
This means that a key can be garbage collected even if it's still present in the expando (as long as there are no other references to it).

For all other intents and purposes it's a map.

Torero

Expando has a very reduced API compared to Map though. You can't iterate through values, or do much else other than use the square bracket notation [] to access elements. You remove elements via expando[obj] = null, because there is no .remove method. – Zurkow

Answer 3

I played with it a little bit. Here's what I've got.

import 'dart:html';

const String cHidden = 'hidden';

class ExpandoElement {
  static final Expando<ExpandoElement> expando =
      new Expando<ExpandoElement>("ExpandoElement.expando");

  final Element element;

  const ExpandoElement._expand(this.element);

  static Element expand(Element element) {
    if (expando[element] == null)
      expando[element] = new ExpandoElement._expand(element);
    return element;
  }

//  bool get hidden => element.hidden; // commented out to test noSuchMethod()
  void set hidden(bool hidden) {
    if (element.hidden = hidden)
      element.classes.add(cHidden);
    else
      element.classes.remove(cHidden);
  }

  noSuchMethod(InvocationMirror invocation) => invocation.invokeOn(element);
}
final Expando<ExpandoElement> x = ExpandoElement.expando;
Element xquery(String selector) => ExpandoElement.expand(query(selector));

final Element input = xquery('#input');

void main() {
  input.classes.remove(cHidden);
  assert(!input.classes.contains(cHidden));

  input.hidden = true;
  assert(x[input].hidden); // Dart Editor warning here, but it's still true
  assert(!input.classes.contains(cHidden)); // no effect

  input.hidden = false;
  assert(!x[input].hidden); // same warning, but we'll get input.hidden via noSuchMethod()
  assert(!input.classes.contains(cHidden));

  x[input].hidden = true;
  assert(input.hidden); // set by the setter of ExpandoElement.hidden
  assert(input.classes.contains(cHidden)); // added by the setter
  assert(x[input].hidden);
  assert(x[input].classes.contains(cHidden)); // this is input.classes

  x[input].hidden = false;
  assert(!input.hidden); // set by the setter
  assert(!input.classes.contains(cHidden)); // removed by the setter
  assert(!x[input].hidden);
  assert(!x[input].classes.contains(cHidden));

  // confused?
  assert(input is Element);
  assert(x[input] is! Element); // is not
  assert(x[input] is ExpandoElement);
  assert(x is Expando<ExpandoElement>);
}

Bini

On the day I post this, Dart version is r19425 – Bini

if (element.hidden = hidden) <-- Not sure but this looks very suspicious, care to elaborate? – Judejudea