What is the difference between IPoIB and TCP over InfiniBand?

Question

Can someone explain the concepts of IPoIB and TCP over InfiniBand? I understand the overall concept and data rates provided by native InfiniBand, but don't quite understand how TCP and IPoIB fit in. Why do you need them and what do they do? What is the difference when someone says their network uses IPoIB or TCP with InfiniBand? Which one is better? I do not have a strong networking background, so it would be nice if you could elaborate.

Eyeless

IP is a network layer protocol (level 3), TCP is a transport layer level (level 4) protocol, so TCP often runs on top of IP (which typically runs on top of Ethernet or Infiniband as you mention). – Loftin

Answer 1

InfiniBand adapters ("HCAs") provide a couple of advanced features that can be used via the native "verbs" programming interface:

1. Data transfers can be initiated directly from userspace to the hardware, bypassing the kernel and avoiding the overhead of a system call.
2. The adapter can handle all of the network protocol of breaking a large message (even many megabytes) into packets, generating/handling ACKs, retransmitting lost packets, etc. without using any CPU on either the sender or receiver.

IPoIB (IP-over-InfiniBand) is a protocol that defines how to send IP packets over IB; and for example Linux has an "ib_ipoib" driver that implements this protocol. This driver creates a network interface for each InfiniBand port on the system, which makes an HCA act like an ordinary NIC.

IPoIB does not make full use of the HCAs capabilities; network traffic goes through the normal IP stack, which means a system call is required for every message and the host CPU must handle breaking data up into packets, etc. However it does mean that applications that use normal IP sockets will work on top of the full speed of the IB link (although the CPU will probably not be able to run the IP stack fast enough to use a 32 Gb/sec QDR IB link).

Since IPoIB provides a normal IP NIC interface, one can run TCP (or UDP) sockets on top of it. TCP throughput well over 10 Gb/sec is possible using recent systems, but this will burn a fair amount of CPU. To your question, there is not really a difference between IPoIB and TCP with InfiniBand -- they both refer to using the standard IP stack on top of IB hardware.

The real difference is between using IPoIB with a normal sockets application versus using native InfiniBand with an application that has been coded directly to the native IB verbs interface. The native application will almost certainly get much higher throughput and lower latency, while spending less CPU on networking.

Donte