HMAC-SHA1: How to do it properly in Java?

Question

I'm hashing some values using HMAC-SHA1, using the following code in Java:

public static String hmacSha1(String value, String key) {
    try {
        // Get an hmac_sha1 key from the raw key bytes
        byte[] keyBytes = key.getBytes();           
        SecretKeySpec signingKey = new SecretKeySpec(keyBytes, "HmacSHA1");

        // Get an hmac_sha1 Mac instance and initialize with the signing key
        Mac mac = Mac.getInstance("HmacSHA1");
        mac.init(signingKey);

        // Compute the hmac on input data bytes
        byte[] rawHmac = mac.doFinal(value.getBytes());

        // Convert raw bytes to Hex
        byte[] hexBytes = new Hex().encode(rawHmac);

        //  Covert array of Hex bytes to a String
        return new String(hexBytes, "UTF-8");
    } catch (Exception e) {
        throw new RuntimeException(e);
    }
}

Hex() belongs to org.apache.commons.codec

In PHP there's a similar function hash_hmac(algorithm, data, key) that I use to compare the values returned by my Java implementation.

So the first try is:

hash_hmac("sha1", "helloworld", "mykey") // PHP

that returns: 74ae5a4a3d9996d5918defc2c3d475471bbf59ac

My Java function returns 74ae5a4a3d9996d5918defc2c3d475471bbf59ac as well.

Ok, it seems working. Then I try to use a more complex key:

hash_hmac("sha1", "helloworld", "PRIE7$oG2uS-Yf17kEnUEpi5hvW/#AFo") // PHP

that returns: e98bcc5c5be6f11dc582ae55f520d1ec4ae29f7a

While this time my Java impl returns: c19fccf57c613f1868dd22d586f9571cf6412cd0

The hash returned by my PHP code is not equal to the value returned by my Java function, and I can't find out why.

Any tips?

Nullity

Wouldn't it interpret $ chars in PHP as variable? – Agraffe

Why do you need the hex phase? – Lyophilic

I have kind of same issue and unable to resolve it #60971703 – Kriegspiel

Answer 1

On your PHP side, use single-quotes around the key so that the $ character is not treated as a variable reference. i.e.,

hash_hmac("sha1", "helloworld", 'PRIE7$oG2uS-Yf17kEnUEpi5hvW/#AFo')

Otherwise, the key you really get is PRIE7-Yf17kEnUEpi5hvW/#AFo (assuming the variable $oG2uS is not defined).

Nonaligned

Answer 2

Recommend Apache Common Codec Library, quite simple and easy to use. HmacUtils.hmacSha1Hex(key, string_to_sign);

Arondell

Deprecated. Use this instead now: new HmacUtils(HmacAlgorithms.HMAC_SHA_1, key).hmacHex(inputStreamOfContent); – Hoggish

Answer 3

The other answers pointing out HmacUtils from Apache commons have been deprecated by now. Apache commons now recommends using:

new HmacUtils(HmacAlgorithms.HMAC_SHA_1, key).hmacHex(string_to_sign)

Burglarious

Answer 4

Any $ symbol in double quotes ("") is regarded as a a variable in PHP. You can avoid the error by using either single quotes as pointed out by the previous commenter or you can escape the dollar sign as below

hash_hmac("sha1", "helloworld", "PRIE7\$oG2uS-Yf17kEnUEpi5hvW/#AFo")

Notice $ is now \$

Unpopular

Answer 5

In Java, and using maven:

Add the below dependency into the pom.xml:

 <!-- https://mvnrepository.com/artifact/commons-codec/commons-codec -->
    <dependency>
        <groupId>commons-codec</groupId>
        <artifactId>commons-codec</artifactId>
        <version>1.4</version>
    </dependency>

and then try to sign it using this

HmacUtils.hmacSha1Hex(key, string_to_sign);

Topsyturvydom

hmacSha1Hex is deprecated please update your answer – Doityourself