is the CollabNet SVN Server as good as VisualSVN Server?

S

6

5

the tigris website

http://subversion.tigris.org/getting.html#windows

has a link to another svn server, which is called CollabNet SVN Server. Does someone use it and know it is better or as good as the VisualSVN Server?

Simoneaux answered 11/5, 2009 at 16:43 Comment(0)

E

17

Actually, CollabNet has the original source code of subversion. Check this out from Wikipedia:

In 2000, CollabNet started the open source project Subversion, a version control system with over 5 million users.

What VisualSVN does is to package this with a small HTTP server and to add a bunch of UI to make it easier for non-advanced users (and they do it very well). In the change log it is documented how they are incorporating -original- SVN versions, currently 1.6.1

Ezekiel answered 11/5, 2009 at 16:55 Comment(0)

I

3

I'd say the biggest difference is that you have to configure the CollabNet's server package manually, while VisualSVN comes with a nice UI where you can do the configuration.

Illlooking answered 11/5, 2009 at 16:48 Comment(0)

S

1

We use CollabNet's server package where I work (I introduced version control where I work, and so far only my project uses version control).

Basically, they're the same thing. VisualSVN comes with a module that automatically plugs into the windows network for authentication. CollabNet's svn server has to be configured to authenticate through windows.

Since I haven't done that configuration step yet we authenticate through the .htaccess file and apache's authentication module.

Soonsooner answered 11/5, 2009 at 16:47 Comment(1)

I really like the "one-check" Windows authentication configuration VisualSVN has. – Web 11/5, 2009 at 16:49

V

1

CollabNet works great, but it doesn't have the visual interfaces for management that are included in VisualSVN.

If they are not important to you, and you're comfortable using standard SVN command line commands, CollabNet is a nice option.

Vally answered 11/5, 2009 at 16:48 Comment(0)

S

0

CollabNet released a new subversion server software:

http://www.open.collab.net/go/csvne2_r2a/

I did not yet try it but I looks like this would beat VisualSVN Server easily...

Savina answered 26/1, 2011 at 17:8 Comment(1)

We are currently running Subversion Edge and I am quite happy with it. Configuring SSPI requires some manual work, but the rest works very nicely out-of-the-box. Updating the installation has never been easier... – Savina 27/6, 2011 at 15:39

S

-1

In addition, VisualSVN doesn't support svn:// protocol which I hear is faster than http/https://. Would like someone to correct me if I am wrong

Shaky answered 9/7, 2009 at 14:20 Comment(1)

Just for reference, Subversion Edge also doesn't support svn:// protocol. – Devolution 25/5, 2012 at 9:59

Recommended topics

Hot tags