Cannot set a default Nhibernate isolation level (eg via mapping)

Question

This has been a problem that has existed on 3 projects for me.

I have tried the following:

<property name="connection.isolation">ReadCommitted</property>

Set in hibernate.cfg.xml

Using fluent nhiberate:

MsSqlConfiguration.MsSql2008.IsolationLevel(IsolationLevel.ReadCommitted);

Set in global.asax.cs

I have always been forced to set it like so:

CurrentNhibernateSession.Transaction.Begin(IsolationLevel.ReadCommitted);

which works. (I can see this using NHibernate Profiler)

The problem is now I am using sharp architecture and transaction.begin is called inside that framework and I am having trouble rebuilding it.

Is there a way to do this that works without explicitly setting it when you begin a transaction?

Breslau

Answer 1

Are you certain that this is the case? If you're only verifying the isolation level by what NHProf is telling you; that could be a problem. Remember that NHProf is only reporting what the logging infrastructure in NHibernate feeds it. Perhaps the isolation level message isn't sent when you open a transaction with the default? This could probably be verified by investigating the NHibernate source.

I would suggest using an alternate means to verify the transaction level (perhaps SQL Profiler?) before concluding that this isn't working as expected.

Edit:

I've had a look at the NHibernate source and can verify my hunch above. If you have a look at the AdoTransaction source you'll note that it is logging an isolation level of IsolationLevel.Unspecified when a transaction is started without specifying a specific isolation level.

// This is the default overload you're calling:
public void Begin()
{
Begin(IsolationLevel.Unspecified);
}

// This is the full method impl
public void Begin(IsolationLevel isolationLevel)
{
// snip....

// This is the problematic line here; it will report an isolationLevel of Unspecified.
log.Debug(string.Format("Begin ({0})", isolationLevel));

// snip...

}

However, the actual transaction is being started with the isolation level specified in the config a few lines down as such:

if (isolationLevel == IsolationLevel.Unspecified)
{
isolationLevel = session.Factory.Settings.IsolationLevel;
}

So, it would seem that NHProf is not being entirely accurate in this instance.

Update:

It appears this has been fixed in the trunk version of NHibernate, so I'm guessing this is no longer an issue with NHibernate 3.xx.

Morice

@Alistair: I mentioned this in the nhprof group as well, but I'm guessing nothing can/will be done about this for NH 2.x users anyways... groups.google.com/group/nhprof/browse_thread/thread/… – Morice

Answer 2

Looks like your property setting should be called hibernate.connection.isolation...

<add key="hibernate.connection.isolation" value="ReadCommitted" />

Regards

Jon

Confiture

This is necessary if you have your nhibernate settings in your web.config. If you have them in an external file then you use the format I specified above. – Breslau