how to instantiate more than one CDI/Weld bean for one class?

Question

In Spring it was possible to instantiate any class by defining the corresponding bean in xml conf. It was also possible to instantiate more then one bean for the same class with different parameters.....

Are the such features in CDI as well, namely is it possible to create different instances of the same class with different initialization parameters?

Is it also possible to create a bean without changing the class....I mean without adding annotation?

ADDED

Let me make an example.

<bean id="someBean1" class="org.mm.MyBean">
    <property name="x" value="xx"/>
    <property name="y" value="yy"/>
    <property name="z" value="zz"/>       
</bean>
<bean id="someBean2" class="org.mm.MyBean">
    <property name="x" value="other value"/>
    <property name="y" value="yy2"/>
    <property name="z" value="zz2"/>       
</bean>

How can instantiate two instances of the same class and initialize them with different field values?

Monagan

Answer 1

Two options as far as I can see:

• Without further knowledge of your usecase, I assume that you either want to provide some alternative implementation for (mock-) testing or configuration issues (say another PaymentProvider for a OrderService). This is supported by the spec itself, have a look at @Alternative here (and don't repeat my initial mistake and forget to activate alternatives in beans.xml)

• To get a Spring-style XML-configuration, you can use Seam 3 Config, which provides XML-configuration just as described. BTW, this has been a part of JSR 299, but has been removed from the spec for whatever reason.

Moynahan

Answered in 2011. What is the current status with EE7? – Aekerly

I have no idea. Maybe start a new question? – Moynahan

Here there is the question #25154124 – Aekerly

Answer 2

there are a few ways to do that.

E.g. use @New

private @Inject @New YourBean yb; private @Inject @New YourBean yb2;

This forces the container to create a new instance, regardless what Scope the bean originally had.

Another way would be to simply define YourBean as being @Dependent scoped (which is btw (currently) the default if a class is not annotated at all).

Ashy

and what about properties?? are they going to be injected? – Monagan

Answer 3

You can easily use producer methods and if you have multiple instances that should be produced by a method use CDI qualifiers to distinguish different types of instances.

Also you can use Seam Config to do it Spring way but i think producer methods are more elegant way of doing this. depending on your use case there is another option which is @Alternative .

Octopus