What is the difference between "show" and "as" in an import statement?

Question

What is the difference between show and as in an import statement?

For example, what's the difference between

import 'dart:convert' show JSON;

and

import 'package:google_maps/google_maps.dart' as GoogleMap;

When do I use show and when should I use as?

If I switch to show GoogleMap all references to GoogleMap (e.g. GoogleMap.LatLng) objects are reported as undefined.

Dhoti

Answer 1

as and show are two different concepts.

With as you are giving the imported library a name. It's usually done to prevent a library from polluting your namespace if it has a lot of global functions. If you use as you can access all functions and classes of said library by accessing them the way you did in your example: GoogleMap.LatLng.

With show (and hide) you can pick specific classes you want to be visible in your application. For your example it would be:

import 'package:google_maps/google_maps.dart' show LatLng;

With this you would be able to access LatLng but nothing else from that library. The opposite of this is:

import 'package:google_maps/google_maps.dart' hide LatLng;

With this you would be able to access everything from that library except for LatLng.

If you want to use multiple classes with the same name you'd need to use as. You also can combine both approaches:

import 'package:google_maps/google_maps.dart' as GoogleMap show LatLng;

Sleeping

What's the point of hiding imported functions? – Reprobative

If you import from 2 libraries which both contain a function or class with the same name, but you only want to use one of them and not use an alias using as, then you would hide the one you don't want to use. – Sleeping

Answer 2

show case:

import 'dart:async' show Stream;

This way you only import Stream class from dart:async, so if you try to use another class from dart:async other than Stream it will throw an error.

void main() {
  List data = [1, 2, 3];
  Stream stream = new Stream.fromIterable(data); // doable
  StreamController controller = new StreamController(); // not doable
                                                        // because you only show Stream
}

as case:

import 'dart:async' as async;

This way you import all class from dart:async and namespaced it with async keyword.

void main() {
  async.StreamController controller = new async.StreamController(); // doable
  List data = [1, 2, 3];
  Stream stream = new Stream.fromIterable(data); // not doable
                                                 // because you namespaced it with 'async'
}

as is usually used when there are conflicting classes in your imported library, for example if you have a library 'my_library.dart' that contains a class named Stream and you also want to use Stream class from dart:async and then:

import 'dart:async';
import 'my_library.dart';

void main() {
  Stream stream = new Stream.fromIterable([1, 2]);
}

This way, we don't know whether this Stream class is from async library or your own library. We have to use as :

import 'dart:async';
import 'my_library.dart' as myLib;

void main() {
  Stream stream = new Stream.fromIterable([1, 2]); // from async
  myLib.Stream myCustomStream = new myLib.Stream(); // from your library
}

For show, I guess this is used when we know we only need a specific class. Also can be used when there are conflicting classes in your imported library. Let's say in your own library you have a class named CustomStream and Stream and you also want to use dart:async, but in this case you only need CustomStream from your own library.

import 'dart:async';
import 'my_library.dart';

void main() {
  Stream stream = new Stream.fromIterable([1, 2]); // not doable
                                                   // we don't know whether Stream 
                                                   // is from async lib ir your own
  CustomStream customStream = new CustomStream();// doable
}

Some workaround:

import 'dart:async';
import 'my_library.dart' show CustomStream;

void main() {
  Stream stream = new Stream.fromIterable([1, 2]); // doable, since we only import Stream
                                                   // async lib
  CustomStream customStream = new CustomStream();// doable
}

Ressieressler

Does using show make the app size smaller since it isn't importing other things that aren't needed? – Sharie

Flutter and dart2js, if not Dart generally, use tree-shaking to make app size smaller. See github.com/dart-lang/sdk/issues/33920 – Depalma

Answer 3

as and show keywords used with library import statement. These two keywords are optional with import keyword, But using these keywords you can provide convenience and additional information about your library importing.

---

show

show give restrictions to access only specific class of that library.

import 'dart:convert' show JSON;

Above dart:convert library contains more than 5 types of converters. (ascii,Base64,Latin1,Utf8 & json are some of them).

But with using show keyword you will give your application source file to access only that JSON converter class only.

warning !! :- if you try to access any other converters like ascii, Base64 or Latin1, you will get an exception. Because using show keyword you give an restriction for only access Json class in that library api.

So if your source file want to access all the class in that library, you cannot define show keyword for that library importing.

---

as

Provide additional namespace for library members.

This as keyword is mostly used when a library that contains lot of global functions.

• You will access static members of a library by Using the class name and . (dot operator). eg:- ClassName.staticFun()

• And also you will access instance methods and variables by using object name and . (dot operator) eg:- obj.instanceFunc()

• And also library source file can have global functions. and we will access them by their name without any parental membership. eg:- func()

So when we access global functions of a different library inside our source file, we didnt have a way to seperatly identified that global function as seperate function of a different library.

But using as keyword, we can add namespace before accessing global functions of that library.

See below example to understanding real benefit of as keyword. 👇

import 'package:http/http.dart' as http;

http library contains lot of global functions. Below shows list of global functions in http library.

• Accessing above http library global functions without http namespace.( import 'package:http/http.dart'; )

   eg:- 
     1.  get("url")
  
     2.  post("url")
  

• Accessing above http library global functions with http namespace. ( import 'package:http/http.dart'as http; )

   eg:- 
     1.  http.get("url")
  
     2.  http.post("url")
  

So using as keyword , makes it easy to identify global functions of a different library separated from our source files' global functions.

Opening

Answer 4

I prefer the dart document, it's described in Libraries and visibility section.

• import as: Specifying a library prefix, for example when import two libraries which has the same function name, then we can give them a prefix to specify the library.
• import show: This is used to import part of the library, show only import one name of the library.
• import hide: This is another one which is the opposite of the show, hide import all names except the name specified in the hide.

Monostrophe