Checkmarx Java fix for Log Forging -sanitizing user input

Question

Can anyone suggest the proper sanitization/validation process required for the courseType variable in the following getCourses method. I am using that variable to write in a log file.

I've tried HtmlUtils.HtmlEscape() but didn't get expected results.

Thanks!

@RequestMapping(value = "/retriveCourses", method = RequestMethod.GET)
@ResponseBody
public List<Course> getCourses(@RequestParam(value = "courseType", required = false) String courseType) {

}

Lytton

Can you add the part of the code where you write to the log? – Globoid

Hi..thanks for the reply. I am writing the @RequestParam to the log as follows -logger.info("Course Type is "+HtmlUtils.HtmlEscape(courseType)). This enabling log forging. – Lytton

Answer 1

it seems like the Checkmarx tool is correct in this case.

A "Log Forging" vulnerability means that an attacker could engineer logs of security-sensitive actions and lay a false audit trail, potentially implicating an innocent user or hiding an incident.

While using htmlEscape will escape some special characters:

• &amplt; represents the < sign.
• &ampgt; represents the > sign.
• &ampamp; represents the & sign.
• &ampquot; represents the " mark.

It will not escape or remove new-line/EOL/tab characters that must be avoided in order to keep logs integrity.

The best practice recommendations to avoid log forging are:

1. Make sure to replace all relevant dangerous characters. example:

   cleanInput = input.replace('\t', '-').replace('\n', '-').replace('\r', '-');

2. Validate all input, regardless of source. Validation should be based on a whitelist. Accept only data fitting a specified structure, rather than reject bad patterns. Check for: Data type, Size, Range, Format, Expected values.

Hopefully, that solves your problem.

Globoid

I am reading an index value from database and then logging that value when some data referred by that index is incorrect or incomplete. Checkmarx complain about log forging but since I am only logging and index from a database I see nothing to sanitize. How could I solve this? – Mucilage

Answer 2

1. Have a look at the Logging - OWASP Cheat Sheet Series in the section 'Event Collection'

2. The best encoder still OWASP Java Encoder => Solve the 2. of @yaloner

3. There is also a project at OWASP To help you to deal withs log injections OWASP Security Logging => Solve the 1. of @yaloner

Have a look at them will solve the issue

Faultless

Direct links to the projects in question: github.com/OWASP/owasp-java-encoder and github.com/javabeanz/owasp-security-logging – Mandrel