Synchronous and asynchronous callbacks

Question

I get confused with some terms while reading MSDN documents and code samples.

What are callbacks in C#? In particular, what are synchronous and asynchronous callbacks ?

Please explain these from a layman's point of view.

Also, please explain the IAsyncCallback IAsyncResult interface. How can we implement it? (with very simple example)

Thanks in advance.

Janis

Answer 1

The IAsyncCallback interface does not exist, so you cannot implement it.

I suspect that you actually want to know about the IAsyncResult interface.

I recommend that you read this page on MSDN.

---

The IAsyncResult interface represents an operation (such as a web request or a database call) that is running in the background, while your code continues to execute. It can tell you whether the operation finished (the IsCompleted property). It also gives you a WaitHandle object (the AsyncWaitHandle property) which can be used to wait until the operation finishes. (By calling result.AsyncWaitHandle.WaitOne())

You get an IAsyncResult by calling a BeginWhatever method. (BeginExecuteReader, BeginGetResponse, and many others). The BeginWhatever method will take any parameters needed for the operation (For example, BeginExecuteReader can take a CommandBehavior parameter), and can take an AsyncCallback delegate (not interface) and a state parameter. In returns an IAsyncResult object.

The AsyncCallback delegate is a method that you supply, which will be called when the operation finishes. It will usually be called on a different thread, so be careful in it. Your AsyncCallback method will be given the same IAsyncResult that the BeginWhatever method gave you earlier. The state parameter is put into the IAsyncResult and ignored by the system; you can use it in your AsyncCallback method to keep track of what the operation was for. (The state can be whatever you want it to be, including null)

Inside your AsyncCallback (or anywhere else), you can call the EndWhatever method that corresponds to the BeginWhatever method you called in the first place. You have to give it the IAsyncResult from BeginWhatever or from the AsyncCallback. When you call it, it will wait for the operation to finish (if it isn't already finished), and then give you back the operation's result. (Assuming the operation returns something; for example, WebRequest.EndGetResponse will return a WebResponse). If any error occurred during the operation, EndWhatever will throw an exception.

---

You would implement IAsyncResult if you want to create your own operation that can run in the background. You would also create BeginWhatever and EndWhatever methods that return and take it, respectively. For more information on implementing IAsyncResult, see here.

Correggio

Sorry typo error.As you said i need clarification on IAsyncResult.Thank a lot for your explanation. – Janis

Answer 2

With a synchronous callback the calling method (or thread) has to wait until the called method has completed before it can carry on processing - much like an "ordinary" method call.

With an asynchronous callback the calling method (or thread) can carry on processing other inputs or events or whatever without waiting for the called method to complete.

For an applications User Interface thread if you don't want it to "freeze" while the application is performing some lengthy process you need to use asynchronous callbacks.

Microdont

Thanks Chris for your explanation – Janis

No problem - there's much more to it than that and I'd suggesting reading more on MSDN and search here for questions about multi-threading. – Microdont

Sure I will go through MSDN as suggested.Thanks a lot – Janis

Answer 3

A callback is nothing more than a delegate. The term callback is used because you generally pass it (the delegate) into a method (as an argument) and is then invoked in that method to signal something.

Sync and Async callbacks are that. Synchronous, execute on the same thread that called the method (started the action). Async are generally executed on another thread (but not always)

The IAsyncCallback interface is a template to initiate an asynchronous task. You pass in a callback (delegate) which is invoked when the work is complete. There is a property to determine if the method execute synchronously.

Airdry