WhatsApp could access SMS without having permission to it

Asked 30/1, 2019 at 5:7 Answered 13/2, 2024 at 20:3

I have not granted SMS permission to WhatsApp on my device HonorView10 running on EMUI9. Recently I changed the number registered with WhatsApp and it send the verification code to new number (the sim is on same device as it is dual SIM). WhatsApp read the SMS and completed the verification process. Is it possible in Android to read SMS without permission? Or it is bug in EMUI9? I am just curious.

Butters answered 30/1, 2019 at 5:7 Comment(4)

Woah!!. Cross Check by going to settings>whatsapp>app permissions>here check if you have granted read sms permission. – Pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis 30/1, 2019 at 5:12

Definitely doesn't seem like it's using the normal approach. Reading any SMS requires the permission, which you've clearly not given it. – Barn 30/1, 2019 at 5:19

There might be something wrong with your custom UI, because as an android developer and after checking in 2-3 android devices available with me this is not the case for me. Please cross check the same scenario in some other android device. May be we can have some idea on this. By the way nice question, I'm getting curious too. – Mcclees 30/1, 2019 at 5:29

@DeepPatel, there seems no issue in UI. The other permissions (granted/not granted to WhatsApp) are working perfectly fine. Just additional info - its Android Pie and latest version of WhatsApp. Also, the following answer by NileshRathod seems plausible as it is standard Android provision. – Butters 30/1, 2019 at 9:3

WhatsApp could access SMS without having permission to it

I think whats app is using SMS Retriever API

SMS Retriever API

With the SMS Retriever API, you can perform SMS-based user verification in your Android app automatically, without requiring the user to manually type verification codes, and without requiring any extra app permissions. When you implement automatic SMS verification in your app, the verification flow looks like this

Jesse answered 30/1, 2019 at 5:44 Comment(0)

Watssap does access messages in other apps, my phone set up with signal as messaging app and signal is locked, but when setting up watssap it asked me if I want to allow watssap to read messages for verification I clicked no and entered pin manually, after 2min when setting up clone app for dual sim it suddenly read sms message that came to signal app without even asking to unlock app

Tench answered 25/8, 2022 at 22:34 Comment(0)

One of the ways the spyware Pegasus is installed is through having WhatsApp read sms's in the background

Darrendarrey answered 13/2, 2024 at 20:3 Comment(0)

-5

In some circumstances, you want to help the user understand why your app needs a permission. For example, if a user launches a photography app, the user probably won't be surprised that the app asks for permission to use the camera, but the user might not understand why the app wants access to the user's location or contacts. Before your app requests a permission, you should consider providing an explanation to the user. Keep in mind that you don't want to overwhelm the user with explanations; if you provide too many explanations, the user might find the app frustrating and remove it.

read this https://developer.android.com/training/permissions/requesting

Hershelhershell answered 30/1, 2019 at 5:20 Comment(1)

user can understood the use of devices hardware and access the device predefined services , so in new version devices we needs run time permission – Hershelhershell 30/1, 2019 at 5:23

Recommended topics

Hot tags