Xamarin.Android JmDNS binding issues

Question

I started work on a JmDNS bindings for Xamarin.Android. I managed to get the binding to build but I can not reference it from within my code. https://github.com/ytn3rd/monodroid-bindings/tree/master/JmDNS

First issue I had was there was no IDNSListener class to reference. So I added a partial interface in there for it. I have the function it needs void updateRecord(DNSCache dnsCache, long now, DNSEntry record); commented out as it would complain on not being able to reference DNSCache or DNSEntry. (I believe I removed DNSCache and thats why)

Not sure if some of the things I have done were bad, just removing nodes to get it to compile. For instnace. I added this to remove to following errors.

E:\Users\brads_000\Documents\GitHub\ytn3rd\monodroid-bindings\JmDNS\bindings\obj\Debug\generated\src\Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.cs(24,24): Error CS0738: 'Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.SubTypeEntry' does not implement interface member 'Java.Util.IMapEntry.Key'. 'Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.SubTypeEntry.Key' cannot implement 'Java.Util.IMapEntry.Key' because it does not have the matching return type of 'Java.Lang.Object'. (CS0738) (JmDNS-Bindings) E:\Users\brads_000\Documents\GitHub\ytn3rd\monodroid-bindings\JmDNS\bindings\obj\Debug\generated\src\Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.cs(24,24): Error CS0738: 'Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.SubTypeEntry' does not implement interface member 'Java.Util.IMapEntry.Value'. 'Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.SubTypeEntry.Value' cannot implement 'Java.Util.IMapEntry.Value' because it does not have the matching return type of 'Java.Lang.Object'. (CS0738) (JmDNS-Bindings)

Issue is from the Java.Util.IMapEntry class. I thought correct action would be to create my own parital SubEntryType and then override the string Key property but it would not pick it up. My next attempt was to do this.

Java.Lang.Object

Which would resolve that error, but would then cause an error with

E:\Users\brads_000\Documents\GitHub\ytn3rd\monodroid-bindings\JmDNS\bindings\obj\Debug\generated\src\Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.cs(12,12): Error CS1502: The best overloaded method match for 'Android.Runtime.JNIEnv.NewString(string)' has some invalid arguments (CS1502) (JmDNS-Bindings)

static IntPtr n_GetKey (IntPtr jnienv, IntPtr native__this)
{
    global::Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.SubTypeEntry __this = global::Java.Lang.Object.GetObject<global::Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.SubTypeEntry> (jnienv, native__this, JniHandleOwnership.DoNotTransfer);
    return JNIEnv.NewString (__this.Key);
}
namespace Javax.Jmdns.Impl
{
    public partial class SubTypeEntry
    {
        static IntPtr n_GetKey (IntPtr jnienv, IntPtr native__this)
        {
            global::Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.SubTypeEntry __this = global::Java.Lang.Object.GetObject<global::Javax.Jmdns.Impl.JmDNSImpl.SubTypeEntry> (jnienv, native__this, JniHandleOwnership.DoNotTransfer);
            return JNIEnv.NewString(__this.Key.ToString());
        }
    }
}

But again, it does not want to pick this new method up.

I removed javax.jmdns.impl.DNSCache because of same errors with Key/Value as above and,

E:\Users\brads_000\Documents\GitHub\ytn3rd\monodroid-bindings\JmDNS\bindings\obj\Debug\generated\src\Javax.Jmdns.Impl.DNSCache.cs(95,95): Error CS0508: 'Javax.Jmdns.Impl.DNSCache.EntrySet()': return type must be 'System.Collections.ICollection' to match overridden member 'Java.Util.AbstractMap.EntrySet()' (CS0508) (JmDNS-Bindings)

Which I seemed to have fixed with

System.Collections.ICollection

Even though it is what it was already returning.
public override global::System.Collections.Generic.ICollection EntrySet ()

Anyway, any help would be appreciated to get this awesome library up and running :)

Helli

Which version of JmDNS and Xamarin are you using? – Trichina

Xamarin Studio 5 (build 878). Xamarin.Android v4.12.4. jmdns v3.4.1. – Helli

Answer 1

I was able to build it the binding project correctly. To build it correct please try with the following approach.

1.Rebuild the jar file from the jmdns-3.4.1 source. Make the DNSListener interface public. Remove the test packages. Then export the source to get the updated jar file.

2.Update the jar file created from step 1. Make sure to update the build action to EmbededJar.

3.EnumMethods.xml

<enum-method-mappings>
  <mapping jni-class="javax/jmdns/impl/DNSCache">
    <method jni-name="entrySet" parameter="return" clr-enum-type="System.Collections.ICollection" />
  </mapping>

  <mapping jni-class="javax/jmdns/impl/DNSCache._CacheEntry">
    <method jni-name="getKey" parameter="return" clr-enum-type="Java.Lang.Object" />
  </mapping>

  <mapping jni-class="javax/jmdns/impl/DNSCache._CacheEntry">
    <method jni-name="getValue" parameter="return" clr-enum-type="Java.Lang.Object" />
  </mapping>

  <mapping jni-class="javax/jmdns/impl/JmDNSImpl.ServiceTypeEntry.SubTypeEntry">
    <method jni-name="getKey" parameter="return" clr-enum-type="Java.Lang.Object" />
  </mapping>

  <mapping jni-class="javax/jmdns/impl/JmDNSImpl.ServiceTypeEntry.SubTypeEntry">
    <method jni-name="getValue" parameter="return" clr-enum-type="Java.Lang.Object" />
  </mapping>

  <mapping jni-class="javax/jmdns/impl/JmDNSImpl.ServiceTypeEntry">
    <method jni-name="entrySet" parameter="return" clr-enum-type="System.Collections.ICollection" />
  </mapping>

</enum-method-mappings>

4.In your sample app you have to add one more permission as android.permission.ACCESS_WIFI_STATE.

5.Also all the network operation should be performed from a background thread and notify UI in Main thread. So update your MainActivity class accordingly.

Hope this will help you to create the build correctly. The working copy of the sample code is uploaded here https://github.com/Hitangshu/JmDNS_Xamarin_Library

Marbling

I was able to build the jmdns bindings, but when I went to go use them I got the following error. javax.jmdns.impl.DNSListener is not public in javax.jmdns.impl; cannot be accessed from outside package I have updated my bindings and sample on github (link in OP). I have also included the original .jar and the modified .jar that I downloaded from home.heeere.com/tech-androidjmdns.html which is apparently needed to get JmDNS to work on Android. – Helli

@BradMoore I have updated the answer. Also the link for an working copy of your sample is included in the answer. Hope this will be useful. – Marbling

Got the code and it compiled and ran. Will play around with it to ensure its functional tonight then mark as correct answer! So far so good! Thanks for the help – Helli

For some reason any examples I run won't detect each other. – Helli

Answer 2

Sometimes, when i'm facing difficulties to bind some libraries, i create a wrapper in java, and bind that new library in Xamarin.

I did that with an Unity project that was exported to Java. Unity has a library named UnityPlayer, with it can't (i think it can't) be bind in Xamarin. So i created a another library in java with can call the methods that i need, and returns with bindable returns types.

You'll just need to place the dependencies libraries in the right place. But you can LogCat to get some help.

I hope you can get some progress with that.

Apollonius

That is a great idea! I'll see how I go with that later tonight :) – Helli

any examples you could possibly link me to to get started? – Helli