It is not possible to download large files at Jetty server
Asked Answered
A

2

0

I made a few test downloads using the Jetty 9 server, where it is made multiple downloads of a single file with an approximate size of 80 MB. When smaller number of downloads and the time of 55 seconds is not reached to download, all usually end, however if any downloads in progress after 55 seconds the flow of the network simply to download and no more remains.

I tried already set the timeout and the buffer Jetty, though this has not worked. Has anyone had this problem or have any suggestions on how to solve? Tests on IIS and Apache Server work very well. Use JMeter for testing.

Archean answered 6/5, 2015 at 12:34 Comment(0)
R
1

Marcus, maybe you are just hitting Jetty bug 472621?

Edit: The mentioned bug is a separate timeout in Jetty that applies to the total operation, not just idle time. So by setting the http.timeout property you essentially define a maximum time any download is allowed to take, which in turn may cause timeout errors for slow clients and/or large downloads.

Cheers, momo

Ragi answered 15/7, 2015 at 8:0 Comment(0)
C
-1

A timeout means your client isn't reading fast enough.

JMeter isn't reading the response data fast enough, so the connection sits idle long enough that it idle times out and disconnects.

We test with 800MB and 2GB files regularly.

On using HTTP/1.0, HTTP/1.1, and HTTP/2 protocols.

Using normal (plaintext) connections, and secured TLS connections.

With responses being delivered in as many Transfer-Encodings and Content-Encodings as we can think of (compressed, gzip, chunked, ranged, etc.).

We do all of these tests using our own test infrastructure, often spinning up many many Amazon EC2 nodes to perform a load test that can sufficiently test the server demands (a typical test is 20 client nodes to 1 server node)

When testing large responses, you'll need to be aware of the protocol (HTTP/1.x vs HTTP/2) and how persistence behavior of that protocol can change the request / response latency. In the real world you wont have multiple large requests after each other on the same persisted connection via HTTP/1 (on HTTP/2 the multiple requests would be parallel and be sent at the same time).

Be sure you setup your JMeter to use HTTP/1.1 and not use persisted connections. (see JMeter documentation for help on that)

Also be aware of your bandwidth for your testing, its very common to blame a server (any server) for not performing fast enough, when the test itself is sloppily setup and has expectations that far exceed the bandwidth of the network itself.

Next, don't test with the same machine, this sort of load test would need multiple machines (1 for the server, and 4+ for the client)

Lastly, when load testing, you'll want to become intimately aware of your networking configurations on your server (and to a lesser extent, your client test machines) to maximize your network configuration for high load. Default configurations for OS's are rarely sufficient to handle proper load testing.

Coretta answered 6/5, 2015 at 13:1 Comment(1)
I changed the line below the Jetty start.ini increasing the time for something close to 5 minutes and the downloads have been completed. If the problem happened when 30 devices lowered the same file server, where most of them stopped. That would be the best thing to do? ## HTTP idle timeout in milliseconds http.timeout=300000Archean

© 2022 - 2024 — McMap. All rights reserved.