Android Network Discovery Service (ish) before API 14

Question

I need to be able to discover the services on the local network (so say I am running a chat application and I want to discover other devices on local network running this chat), but sadly I need to be able to use it on devices with API < 16 (so I cannot use android.net.nsd) I am sure this can be done without using NSD API. Question is how. Any help?

Perceval

Answer 1

There are at least three or four options.

You can use

TCP or UDP

1. Broadcast address
2. Multicast address
3. Iterate over all adresses in your network

HTTP

4 Make use of external server or something like GCM (Google Cloud Messaging)

ad.1 and 2

Pros:

+Easy to implement, server is sending predefined "hello" message on broadcast/multicast address of your subnet/network on specific port, client is listening on that port and when "hello" message arrives, he automatically knows server IP address (contained in packet)

+Connection to the Internet is not needed

Cons:

• Some public networks blocks this addresses to avoid attacks (e.g flooding ).

ad 3.

Pros:

When Multicast and Broadcast is blocked what you can do is simply iterate over whole subnet. It is " brute force " method, but works, especially on typical home/small networks where mask is /24 - there are only 255 addresses to iterate through.

Connection to the Internet also is not needed

Cons

When mask is let say /16 it will take pretty much time to iterate all IPs

can cause battery drain

and will flood network.

ad. 4

Another approach is to make some external server that will be "orientation point" for devices. Each of them sends up its own Address, and looks if there are some entries from another devices from the same network.

Of course Internet connection is needed.

So, I think it is good idea to start with broadcast and multicast since it is very simply and will work in many places, but keep in mind that there are networks where it is not allowed to use.

Good reference can be found here http://docs.oracle.com/javase/tutorial/networking/datagrams/broadcasting.html

You should also check this one http://home.heeere.com/tech-androidjmdns.html

Kawasaki

OK, thanks for answer. The Example you suggested almost works :-) I managed to make both phones recognize my workstation, but I wasn't able to make phones see each other. Still trying thought. – Perceval

@nivwusquorum any update on this? I suspect you were suffering from client-isolation function on your AP. – Hoang