Convert from Oracle's RAW(16) to .NET's GUID

Question

I'm having difficulties manually debugging an .NET application where the Guid values differ from .NET to Oracle.

• Where C# reads:
  • 17D89D326C2142D69B989F5201288DBF
• Oracle reads:
  
  • 329DD817216CD6429B989F5201288DBF

How would I be able to manually debug, i.e., from C#'s GUID be able to paste that value in an oracle query and get the correct results (and viceversa)?

Trachyte

Possible duplicate of Convert byte array from Oracle RAW to System.Guid? – Sublease

why why didn't I use string? fml – Selfconsequence

Answer 1

I just had this same issue when storing and reading Guids from Oracle.

Jon's answer is correct for querying but if your app needs to store and read Guids from Oracle, use the FlipEndian function from this thread:

.NET Native GUID conversion

Byte[] rawBytesFromOracle;
Guid dotNetGuid = new Guid(rawBytesFromOracle).FlipEndian();

The flip is only required when reading back from Oracle.

When writing to Oracle use Guid.ToByteArray() as normal.

I spent TOO much time trying to get this simple task accomplished.

Steve

Pontias

Answer 2

If you look at the values involved (in pairs) of hex digits you can see that the last 7 bytes are the same in both cases, but the first 9 are switched around a bit.

Going from your example, but rewriting each pair in the .NET as 00, 11, 22 etc and switching the relevant byte of Oracle as well we get:

• .NET:

  00112233445566778899AABBCCDDEEFF
  

• Oracle:

  33221100554477668899AABBCCFFEEFF
  

So it should be fairly easy to write code to switch round the relevant bytes. (I'm pretty sure I wrote some code to do this in a previous job, in fact.)

To switch round the bytes, you'll just want to call Guid.ToByteArray() and new Guid(byte[]) to get back to a Guid.

EDIT: As it happens, the switch-round above is exactly what the Guid constructor does when you pass it a byte array:

using System;
using System.Linq;

class Test
{
    static void Main()
    {
        byte[] bytes = Enumerable.Range(0, 16)
                                 .Select(x => x * 16 + x)
                                 .Select(x => (byte) x)
                                 .ToArray();

        Console.WriteLine(BitConverter.ToString(bytes).Replace("-", ""));
        Console.WriteLine(new Guid(bytes).ToString().Replace("-", ""));
    }
}

Prints:

00112233445566778899AABBCCDDEEFF
33221100554477668899aabbccddeeff

That may well make it considerably simpler to perform the switching... how were you getting hold of the values to start with? Is it just "how they're displayed in Oracle"?

EDIT: Okay, here are a couple of conversion functions - if you've got the data as text, they'll convert each way...

using System;
using System.Linq;

class Test
{
    static void Main()
    {
        string oracle = "329DD817216CD6429B989F5201288DBF";
        string dotNet = "17D89D326C2142D69B989F5201288DBF";

        Console.WriteLine(oracle == DotNetToOracle(dotNet));
        Console.WriteLine(dotNet == OracleToDotNet(oracle));
    }

    static string OracleToDotNet(string text)
    {
        byte[] bytes = ParseHex(text);
        Guid guid = new Guid(bytes);
        return guid.ToString("N").ToUpperInvariant();
    }

    static string DotNetToOracle(string text)
    {
        Guid guid = new Guid(text);
        return BitConverter.ToString(guid.ToByteArray()).Replace("-", "");
    }

    static byte[] ParseHex(string text)
    {
        // Not the most efficient code in the world, but
        // it works...
        byte[] ret = new byte[text.Length / 2];
        for (int i = 0; i < ret.Length; i++)
        {
            ret[i] = Convert.ToByte(text.Substring(i * 2, 2), 16);
        }
        return ret;
    }

}

Excommunication

It turns out that it's not Oracle that's reordering things. It's Guid.ToByteArray() and the Guid constructor that takes a byte array as its parameter. I have no idea why it does this, and I've posted a question asking exactly that here: #9196051 – Emblaze

Answer 3

If you need to convert a GUID to RAW from PL/SQL can use this function:

/*
    CONVERT a GUID FORMAT in RAW(16)
    EX:
        guid    = 88c6a267-65d2-48d6-8da2-6f45e2c22726
        raw     = 67A2C688D265D6488DA26F45E2C22726
*/
FUNCTION GuidToRaw( guid IN VARCHAR2 ) RETURN RAW
IS
    ret         RAW(16);
    guidHex     VARCHAR2(64);
BEGIN

    guidHex := SUBSTR (guid, 7, 2);
    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 5, 2) );
    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 3, 2) );
    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 1, 2) );

    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 12, 2) );
    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 10, 2) );

    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 17, 2) );
    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 15, 2) );

    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 20, 2) );
    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 22, 2) );

    guidHex := CONCAT( guidHex, SUBSTR (guid, 25, 12) );

    ret := HEXTORAW( guidHex );

    return ret;

end;

Trierarch

Answer 4

Just use always your standard GUID in .NET...

When you want to insert some GUID into Oracle you just call Guid.ToString ( "N") and feed that string to Oracle (in this example the param name is MyNETVAL):

INSERT INTO MyTable ( MyRAWCol)
SELECT HEXTORAW (SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 6, 2) || SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 4, 2) || SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 2, 2) || SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 0, 2) || SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 10, 2) || SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 8, 2) || SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 14, 2) || SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 12, 2) || SUBSTR (MyNETVal, 16, 16)) FROM DUAL;

When you read a RAW from Oracle you use:

SELECT 
SUBSTR (HexV, 6, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 4, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 2, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 0, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 10, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 8, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 14, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 12, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 16, 16) AS MyNETVal
FROM (SELECT RAWTOHEX (MyRAWCol) HexV FROM MyTable);

Then you can feed the returned MyNETVal into new Guid (MyNETVal).

This way your code always deals with the .NET format and the byte switching occurs in the Oracle-DB... you don't polute your code with conversion code and can keep the code code the same when switchig to other DBs - just change the SQL and you are up and running... the SQL could get simpler with other DBs because some of them follow the GUID format of Windows...

Raphaelraphaela

that's not what OP is asking. If I knew .NET would screw up IDs I would opt for VARCHAR2 straight away. But now it is too late, now I need to figure how to match them – Selfconsequence

Your subst is off by one (substr is 1 based). – Anastomosis

Correct RAW to GUID due to SUBSTR based on 1 (not 0): SELECT SUBSTR (HexV, 7, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 5, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 3, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 1, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 11, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 9, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 15, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 13, 2) || SUBSTR (HexV, 17, 16) AS MyNETVal FROM (SELECT RAWTOHEX (MyRAWCol) HexV FROM MyTable); – Desantis