ThreadLocal (and Singleton) in EJB Container

Question

I've written an authorization system which relies on objects representing the current user. To simplify programming and increase performance I want to hold those objects in a ThreadLocal after the user has logged in.

It looks like this:

public class UserCache {

    private static final ThreadLocal<User> cache = new ThreadLocal<User>();

    public User getCurrentUser() {
        return cache.get();
    }

    public void setCurrentUser(User user) {
        cache.set(user);
    }

}

I've read that static elements make clustering problematic. If I had an UserCache on each cluster node, they all had their own cache object not synchronized with the cache objects on other nodes. Right? UserCache is a classic candidate for a singleton, because the application needs only a single instance of it. But as far as I know @Singleton EJBs have the same behaviour in a cluster.

So what to do to make UserCache clusterable in an EJB 3.1 (Java EE 6) environment?

Solutions extracted from the answers:

• Using SessionScope from CDI (JSR 299) or
• Using JVM clustering with Terracotta

Depression

Answer 1

Since you're already on Java EE 6, wouldn't it even be a lot easier to use CDI (Contexts and Dependency Injection). This would allow to put the user info in the session scope, and inject it easily everywhere. CDI manages the rest for you.

Outstrip

Answer 2

that shouldn't cause you a problem, because threads don't span different nodes anyway - or am i missing the point of your question?

edit : you might want to look into something like terracotta - http://www.terracotta.org/ - for ways you can cluster existing objects

Builtup

You're right, my approach with thread local doesn't make much sense in a cluster. So I'll have to go with terracotta or CDI SessionScope, like chris_l suggests. – Depression

Answer 3

If you need to share objects between nodes, I would also suggest looking at the existing frameworks (like Terracotta).

Also, using ThreadLocal might possibly cause different problems:

http://forums.sun.com/thread.jspa?threadID=589744 http://www.devwebsphere.com/devwebsphere/2005/06/dont_use_thread.html http://www.theserverside.com/discussions/thread.tss?thread_id=21055

This may not be an issue here, though.

Clevie