Why doesn't boost regex '.{2}' match '??'

Question

I'm trying to match some chunks if interesting data within a data stream.

There should be a leading < then four alphanumeric characters, two characters of checksum (or ?? if no shecksum was specified) and a trailing >.

If the last two characters are alphanumeric, the following code works as expected. If they're ?? though it fails.

// Set up a pre-populated data buffer as an example
std::string haystack = "Fli<data??>bble";

// Set up the regex
static const boost::regex e("<\\w{4}.{2}>");
std::string::const_iterator start, end;
start = haystack.begin();
end = haystack.end();
boost::match_flag_type flags = boost::match_default;

// Try and find something of interest in the buffer
boost::match_results<std::string::const_iterator> what;
bool succeeded = regex_search(start, end, what, e, flags); // <-- returns false

I've not spotted anything in the documentation which suggests this should be the case (all but NULL and newline should be match AIUI).

So what have I missed?

Gesticulate

What compiler are you using? Mine (gcc) gives an explicit warning saying "trigraph ??> converted to }". – Sicken

I'm using visual studio 2013 with the 2008 tool chain. – Gesticulate

Answer 1

Because ??> is a trigraph, it will be converted to }, Your code is equivalent to:

// Set up a pre-populated data buffer as an example
std::string haystack = "Fli<data}bble";

// Set up the regex
static const boost::regex e("<\\w{4}.{2}>");
std::string::const_iterator start, end;
start = haystack.begin();
end = haystack.end();
boost::match_flag_type flags = boost::match_default;

// Try and find something of interest in the buffer
boost::match_results<std::string::const_iterator> what;
bool succeeded = regex_search(start, end, what, e, flags); // <-- returns false

You can change to this:

std::string haystack = "Fli<data?" "?>bble";

Demo (note: I use std::regex which is more or less the same)

NOTE: trigraph is deprecated from C++11, will be (likely) removed from C++17

Diversification

You got it. Very interesting - I'd not heard of trigraphs before! – Gesticulate

They got removed (or deprecated?) in latest standards – Flaxman

@Flaxman deprecated from C++11, will be removed by C++17 – Diversification