undefined method `encode' for URI:Module with gem Rspotify

Question

I am using gem rspotify to access spotify's api in my rails app. The rails version is 6.0.4 but most importantly the Ruby version is 3.0.0

I keep getting this error "undefined method `encode' for URI:Module" when I try to call the api methods. I have to stress that I do not get this error when I downgrade to Ruby 2.6.3. It seems like Ruby 3.0.0 has not support for URI encode. My users controller is the code sample below. I get the error with spotify_user.country and other api methods.

class UsersController < ApplicationController
  skip_before_action :authenticate_user!, only: [ :spotify]

  def spotify
    spotify_user = RSpotify::User.new(request.env['omniauth.auth'])
    spotify_user.country
  end
end

In config/application.rb

RSpotify::authenticate(ENV['SPOTIFY_CLIENT_ID'], ENV['SPOTIFY_CLIENT_SECRET'])

In devise.rb, I have

require 'rspotify/oauth'

Rails.application.config.middleware.use OmniAuth::Builder do
  provider :spotify, ENV['SPOTIFY_CLIENT_ID'], ENV['SPOTIFY_CLIENT_SECRET'], scope: 
  'user-read-email playlist-modify-public user-library-read user-library-modify'
end

I will like to know if there is a solution for the error that does not involve downgrading the ruby version

Nealson

Answer 1

I upgraded from Ruby 2.4.5 to Ruby 3.0.2 and the solution for me was to replace

URI.encode

with

CGI.escape

Potboiler

Thanks, But they are not completely interchangeable #2824626 – Colchicum

Answer 2

URI.encode was an alias for URI.escape that was in turn considered (and reported) obsoleted for quite a while.

It would be better to see the backtrace for the error you ask about, but I guess it fails here.

As you can see here, RSpotify is not consistent and uses URI.encode in one place and Addressable::URI.encode in another. Chances are this was a conscious decision but at first glance it looks just like an accidental thing.

There are a couple of solutions for your problem:

1. Fork RSpotify, fix the issue (replace all occurrences of URI.encode with Addressable::URI.encode, for example) and create a PR to upstream. You can use your fixed fork in the meantime, if in a rush with the upgrade.

2. You can monkey-patch URI itself adding a removed encode method back. Not a good idea at all, but still an option...

3. Replace RSpotify with some other client. The most involving one so put here just for completeness :)

Sisterinlaw

Answer 3

In pure Ruby, for Ruby 3.X:

URL-encode for whole URL:

URI::Parser.new.escape

URL-encode for URL component:

CGI.escape

For examples, see yard doc here and tests here.

Rectocele