How to fix "remote: ssl required" when pushing to Bitbucket?

Question

I am getting the above error whenever I try to push my changes. I am using TortoiseHg as client.

Here is the debug output for hg push:

pushing to https://[email protected]/nulldev/windows-phone    
using https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
proxying through http://[proxy - omitted]
http auth: user nulldev, password not set    
sending capabilities command    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
[HgKeyring] Keyring URL: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Looking for password for user nulldev and url https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Keyring password found. Url: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone, user: nulldev, passwd: ********    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
query 1; heads    
sending batch command    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
[HgKeyring] Keyring URL: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Cached auth data found. Url: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone, user: nulldev, passwd: ********    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
searching for changes    
all remote heads known locally    
sending branchmap command    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
[HgKeyring] Keyring URL: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Cached auth data found. Url: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone, user: nulldev, passwd: ********    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
sending branchmap command    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
[HgKeyring] Keyring URL: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Cached auth data found. Url: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone, user: nulldev, passwd: ********    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
preparing listkeys for "bookmarks"    
sending listkeys command    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
[HgKeyring] Keyring URL: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Cached auth data found. Url: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone, user: nulldev, passwd: ********    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
1 changesets found    
list of changesets:
35b9240f7e7a5eee7936d8559962971e94fab1fc    
bundling: 1/1 changesets (100.00%)    
bundling: 1/1 manifests (100.00%)    
bundling: Key Ring/Controls/BindableApplicationBarIconButton.xaml.cs 1/1 files (100.00%)    
sending unbundle command    
sending 431 bytes    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
sending: 0 kb    
sending: 0 kb    
[HgKeyring] Keyring URL: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Cached auth data found. Url: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone, user: nulldev, passwd: ********    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
sending: 0 kb    
sending: 0 kb    
remote: ssl required    
preparing listkeys for "phases"    
sending listkeys command    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
[HgKeyring] Keyring URL: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Cached auth data found. Url: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone, user: nulldev, passwd: ********    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
try to push obsolete markers to remote    
checking for updated bookmarks    
preparing listkeys for "bookmarks"
sending listkeys command    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified    
[HgKeyring] Keyring URL: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone    
[HgKeyring] Cached auth data found. Url: https://bitbucket.org/nulldev/windows-phone, user: nulldev, passwd: ********    
bitbucket.org certificate successfully verified

Jeanninejeans

You should probably add a little more information, like the repo URL you're trying to push to and any other debug/warning output. – Whitewood

Answer 1

This is usually due to a config issue on the server side (ie on BitBucket's side), as illustrated by this old ticket (which suddenly got a few new entries, all mentioning your error).

pushing to https://[email protected]/nulldev/windows-phone
http authorization required
realm: Bitbucket.org HTTP
user: nulldev
password: 
searching for changes
remote: ssl required

As explained in "Remote repos":

What happens is that Mercurial’s webserver won’t let you push over plain HTTP by default, it requires you to use a HTTPS URL.
Alice can disable this requirement by using --config web.push_ssl=No on the command line when she serves the repository

So I suppose that on BitBucket side, they need to make sure the repo are served with:

hg serve --config web.push_ssl=No --config "web.allow_push=*" 

Dekeles

Thats my entry there! :) Anyways, are you sure I should ask them for changes to their server? Also, what if I do want to push my changes using SSL? – Jeanninejeans

@Jeanninejeans They need to authorize https pushing, and it seems they didn't. They can configure it to authorize both. In the meantime, try indeed a push using ssh, to see if that works. – Dekeles

Well, the ssh wont work for me (something to do with firewall and proxy - its not my home network). – Jeanninejeans

@Jeanninejeans proxy isn't an issue as long as you set the HTTP_PROXY/HTTPS_PROXY environment variables. But for https only, not ssh. Ssh for external sites is always blocked at work, indeed. – Dekeles

The BB guys have started to work on it. They fixed this one, and now I have another - probably unrelated - issue on HTTPS. And yes, ssh is working at my home. I am going to accept this one as answer. – Jeanninejeans