Referencing "this" inside setInterval/setTimeout within object prototype methods [duplicate]

Question

Normally I'd assign an alternative "self" reference when referring to "this" within setInterval. Is it possible to accomplish something similar within the context of a prototype method? The following code errors.

function Foo() {}
Foo.prototype = {
    bar: function () {
        this.baz();
    },
    baz: function () {
        this.draw();
        requestAnimFrame(this.baz);
    }
};

Scandian

Does this help? #2749744 – Oney

Answer 1

Unlike in a language like Python, a Javascript method forgets it is a method after you extract it and pass it somewhere else. You can either

Wrap the method call inside an anonymous function

This way, accessing the baz property and calling it happen at the same time, which is necessary for the this to be set correctly inside the method call.

You will need to save the this from the outer function in a helper variable, since the inner function will refer to a different this object.

var that = this;
setInterval(function(){
    return that.baz();
}, 1000);

Wrap the method call inside a fat arrow function

In Javascript implementations that implement the arrow functions feature, it is possible to write the above solution in a more concise manner by using the fat arrow syntax:

setInterval( () => this.baz(), 1000 );

Fat arrow anonymous functions preserve the this from the surrounding function so there is no need to use the var that = this trick. To see if you can use this feature, consult a compatibility table like this one.

Use a binding function

A final alternative is to use a function such as Function.prototype.bind or an equivalent from your favorite Javascript library.

setInterval( this.baz.bind(this), 1000 );

//dojo toolkit example:
setInterval( dojo.hitch(this, 'baz'), 100);

Handbook

This is a really helpful article about this in js: dmitripavlutin.com/gentle-explanation-of-this-in-javascript – Shults

9 years later... The fat arrow function was badass. Thanks! – Dyson

Answer 2

i made a proxy class :)

function callback_proxy(obj, obj_method_name)
{
    instance_id = callback_proxy.instance_id++;
    callback_proxy.instances[instance_id] = obj;
    return eval('fn = function() { callback_proxy.instances['+instance_id+'].'+obj_method_name+'(); }');
}
callback_proxy.instance_id = 0;
callback_proxy.instances = new Array();

function Timer(left_time)
{
    this.left_time = left_time; //second
    this.timer_id;

    this.update = function()
    {
        this.left_time -= 1;

        if( this.left_time<=0 )
        {
            alert('fin!');
            clearInterval(this.timer_id);
            return;
        }
    }

    this.timer_id = setInterval(callback_proxy(this, 'update'), 1000);
}

new Timer(10);

Ingrate