How to make sure transactions take 0 fee in a private Ethereum blockchain?

Question

I have a private parity node setup on my laptop. How can I make sure that there is 0 transaction fee whenever a transaction is posted in this private ethereum blockchain, meaning that I can post a transaction giving "gas: 0"?

Example: Account A has 20 ether, Account B has 0 ether. When I transfer 10 ether from Account A to Account B, Account A now shows 9.980 and Account B shows 10.

How can I prevent the extra gas being deducted?

Any help is appreciated.

Fallacy

Answer 1

You control the miners in the private network, so you just need to customize them to accept transactions with gasPrice = 0.

From the Parity documentation:

--gasprice WEI                   Minimum amount of Wei per GAS to be paid for a
                                 transaction to be accepted for mining. Overrides
                                 --basic-tx-usd.

Note that this doesn't change how gas itself works in the network. You still have gas limits and can generate out of gas errors. The only difference is that the client is saying it will pay 0 for gas on a transaction and the miner is staying it is willing to accept transactions at 0 price.

EDIT - To address comments:

Admittedly, I use Geth over Parity, but this works in Geth and I'd be surprised if it was once supported in Parity and then disabled. You may have to change the Parity source code to get it to work. Alternatively, you can switch to Geth.

Showing the results in Geth below

Terminal 1

$ geth --networkid 29462 --datadir "./data" --gasprice 0 --nodiscover --port 31313

<Output Truncated>

Terminal 2

$ geth attach '//./pipe/geth.ipc'
Welcome to the Geth JavaScript console!

instance: Geth/v1.8.2-stable-b8b9f7f4/windows-amd64/go1.9.2
coinbase: 0xd69cc234de15189f0ba998a41421961e89837fc5
at block: 79 (Tue, 06 Mar 2018 07:56:30 PST)
 datadir: C:\cygwin\home\adamk\eth\private\node1\data
 modules: admin:1.0 debug:1.0 eth:1.0 miner:1.0 net:1.0 personal:1.0 rpc:1.0 txpool:1.0 web3:1.0

> web3.eth.getBalance('0x1b8c05505f86bf20c6a1110073cd6f9b3bf555df');

2000000000000000000

> web3.eth.sendTransaction({to: '0xd69cc234de15189f0ba998a41421961e89837fc5', from: '0x1b8c05505f86bf20c6a1110073cd6f9b3bf555df', gasLimit: 6000000, gasPrice: 0, value: web3.toWei(1, 'ether')});

"0x1eceea33aee0bd27feccd1d7aba371459090bb60af2cc18d63548112019ac2b9"

> web3.eth.getBalance('0x1b8c05505f86bf20c6a1110073cd6f9b3bf555df');

1000000000000000000

> web3.eth.getTransaction('0x1eceea33aee0bd27feccd1d7aba371459090bb60af2cc18d63548112019ac2b9');

{
  blockHash: "0xad40ce3bfa30b2551dbd085c29ac1800add8b9bc464944625b82fb17df567823",
  blockNumber: 897,
  from: "0x1b8c05505f86bf20c6a1110073cd6f9b3bf555df",
  gas: 90000,
  gasPrice: 0,
  hash: "0x1eceea33aee0bd27feccd1d7aba371459090bb60af2cc18d63548112019ac2b9",
  input: "0x",
  nonce: 0,
  r: "0xc55b5a25f4c7670418f304db44d949f5a077c1b4c8cfcc89b486a84cccb59d22",
  s: "0x7d1d5ee1ed54a0098299d44bd692fc0d3d249609b3c01810beb00180d11e2e35",
  to: "0xd69cc234de15189f0ba998a41421961e89837fc5",
  transactionIndex: 0,
  v: "0x1b",
  value: 1000000000000000000
}

(Note that the initiator of the transfer, 0x1b8c05505f86bf20c6a1110073cd6f9b3bf555df, was decremented by exactly 1 ether. No fees paid.)

Shamikashamma

I did figure this out and found the particular document snippet that you shared. But they have marked this as a part of legacy CLI options. I am using a "node.toml" file to initiate my node and am not able to customize that to add "gasprice 0". In the documentation, they have not specified how to do it. – Fallacy

One more thing, even if I am able to do the above change, when I call a function in my smart contract using web3 giving gas: 0 , it gives me minimal gas error ! – Fallacy

Thanks, Adam. I will do some research on this! – Fallacy

flag provided but not defined: -gasprice – Yenta