Is there a way to @Autowire a bean that requires constructor arguments?

Question

I'm using Spring 3.0.5 and am using @Autowire annotation for my class members as much as possible. One of the beans that I need to autowire requires arguments to its constructor. I've looked through the Spring docs, but cannot seem to find any reference to how to annotate constructor arguments.

In XML, I can use as part of the bean definition. Is there a similar mechanism for @Autowire annotation?

Ex:

@Component
public class MyConstructorClass{

  String var;
  public MyConstructorClass( String constrArg ){
    this.var = var;
  }
...
}


@Service
public class MyBeanService{
  @Autowired
  MyConstructorClass myConstructorClass;

  ....
}

In this example, how do I specify the value of "constrArg" in MyBeanService with the @Autowire annotation? Is there any way to do this?

Thanks,

Eric

Epanaphora

Maybe I wasn't clear, or perhaps I am misunderstanding, but I am not looking to autowire constrArg; I'm looking to autowire MyConstructorClass, but the constructor requires a String. If I was using XML configuration, my bean defn would be: – Epanaphora

If I was using XML configuration, my bean defn would be something like: <bean id="myBeanService" class="MyBeanService"> <property name="myConstructorClass"> <bean class="MyConstructorClass"> <constructor-arg value="MyStringHere" /> </bean> </property> </bean> Is there a way to translate that into annotations? – Epanaphora

baeldung.com/spring-autowire – Burrussburry

Answer 1

You need the @Value annotation.

A common use case is to assign default field values using "#{systemProperties.myProp}" style expressions.

public class SimpleMovieLister {

  private MovieFinder movieFinder;
  private String defaultLocale;

  @Autowired
  public void configure(MovieFinder movieFinder, 
                        @Value("#{ systemProperties['user.region'] }") String defaultLocale) {
      this.movieFinder = movieFinder;
      this.defaultLocale = defaultLocale;
  }

  // ...
}

See: Expression Language > Annotation Configuration

---

To be more clear: in your scenario, you'd wire two classes, MybeanService and MyConstructorClass, something like this:

@Component
public class MyBeanService implements BeanService{
    @Autowired
    public MybeanService(MyConstructorClass foo){
        // do something with foo
    }
}

@Component
public class MyConstructorClass{
    public MyConstructorClass(@Value("#{some expression here}") String value){
         // do something with value
    }
}

Update: if you need several different instances of MyConstructorClass with different values, you should use Qualifier annotations

Unhealthy

Thanks for the tip, but I don't understand how that relates to setting the constructor arg for the injected bean. From what I can tell from the spring docs, it is good for setting default values, but doesn't specify how to pass a constructor arg. – Epanaphora

@EricB. @Value is like @Autowired for string arguments. – Joellenjoelly

@Eric B (awesome username, btw :-)), I've added some sample code for illustration – Unhealthy

Thanks for the tip. The catch here is the requirement for me to have access to modify the MyConstructorClass code. Unfortunately, that is not always the case; I don't necessarily have the ability to modify the code. Additionally, in my example, I'm using a String as the argument, but there are cases where the contructor requires other beans as arguments. – Epanaphora

@Eric well then you either need XML or Java based configuration – Unhealthy

Does this answer change if the constructor arg is a custom java object, ie not a String? – Disquieting

@KevinMeredith well it needs to be an Object Spring can convert, but then it works. However, if your value is a spring bean, you should use @Autowired, @Injectet al – Unhealthy

@SeanPatrickFloyd In the question, an instance of MyConstructorClass is autowired to variable myConstructorClass in MyBeanService. In your example, there is no myConstructorClass variable there. I'm confused. Is it foo argument to be used instead of it? – Embroil

@MikhailBatcer its says "do something with foo". for example: assign foo to a field :-) – Unhealthy

@SeanPatrickFloyd For example, to the field private MyConstructorClass myConstructorClass;, right? :-) – Embroil

@SeanPatrickFloyd - i want to pass the value - "Value1" to the constructor , how can i do it , i tried your syntax , but it is not getting compiled , is it correct ..? can you pls help me – Initial

@AshishShetkar I think the answer contains a typo. Instead of @Value("#{ systemProperties['user.region'] }"} String defaultLocale it needs to be @Value("#{ systemProperties['user.region'] }") String defaultLocale. In my Spring-Boot 4 Project I needed to use @Value("${user.region}") String defaultLocale instead. Don't know the difference though. – Anile

Answer 2

Well, from time to time I run into the same question. As far as I know, one cannot do that when one wants to add dynamic parameters to the constructor. However, the factory pattern may help.

public interface MyBean {
    // here be my fancy stuff
}

public interface MyBeanFactory {
    public MyBean getMyBean(/* bean parameters */);
}

@Component
public class MyBeanFactoryImpl implements MyBeanFactory {
    @Autowired
    WhateverIWantToInject somethingInjected;

    public MyBean getMyBean(/* params */) {
        return new MyBeanImpl(/* params */);
    }

    private class MyBeanImpl implements MyBean {
        public MyBeanImpl(/* params */) {
            // let's do whatever one has to
        }
    }
}

@Component
public class MyConsumerClass {
    @Autowired
    private MyBeanFactory beanFactory;

    public void myMethod() {
        // here one has to prepare the parameters
        MyBean bean = beanFactory.getMyBean(/* params */);
    }
}

Now, MyBean is not a spring bean per se, but it is close enough. Dependency Injection works, although I inject the factory and not the bean itself - one has to inject a new factory on top of his own new MyBean implementation if one wants to replace it.

Further, MyBean has access to other beans - because it may have access to the factory's autowired stuff.

And one might apparently want to add some logic to the getMyBean function, which is extra effort I allow, but unfortunately I have no better solution. Since the problem usually is that the dynamic parameters come from an external source, like a database, or user interaction, therefore I must instantiate that bean only in mid-run, only when that info is readily available, so the Factory should be quite adequate.

Acinaciform

Answer 3

In this example, how do I specify the value of "constrArg" in MyBeanService with the @Autowire annotation? Is there any way to do this?

No, not in the way that you mean. The bean representing MyConstructorClass must be configurable without requiring any of its client beans, so MyBeanService doesn't get a say in how MyConstructorClass is configured.

This isn't an autowiring problem, the problem here is how does Spring instantiate MyConstructorClass, given that MyConstructorClass is a @Component (and you're using component-scanning, and therefore not specifying a MyConstructorClass explicitly in your config).

As @Sean said, one answer here is to use @Value on the constructor parameter, so that Spring will fetch the constructor value from a system property or properties file. The alternative is for MyBeanService to directly instantiate MyConstructorClass, but if you do that, then MyConstructorClass is no longer a Spring bean.

Freezer

Can @Value be set to a fully qualified bean? And them via Autowiring it'll be found? – Disquieting

Answer 4

You can also configure your component like this :

package mypackage;
import org.springframework.context.annotation.Configuration;
   @Configuration
   public class MyConstructorClassConfig {


   @Bean
   public MyConstructorClass myConstructorClass(){
      return new myConstructorClass("foobar");
   }
  }
}

With the Bean annotation, you are telling Spring to register the returned bean in the BeanFactory.

So you can autowire it as you wish.

Percussion

Could you please tell how I can autowire e.g. a client I created in the MyConstructorClassConfig as shown above e.g. I have a createClient method annotated with a Bean, how do I use this createClient method in a service class? – Massacre

What if the parameter is dynamic? – Overlay

Answer 5

An alternative would be instead of passing the parameters to the constructor you might have them as getter and setters and then in a @PostConstruct initialize the values as you want. In this case Spring will create the bean using the default constructor. An example is below

@Component
public class MyConstructorClass{

  String var;

  public void setVar(String var){
     this.var = var;
  }

  public void getVar(){
    return var;
  }

  @PostConstruct
  public void init(){
     setVar("var");
  }
...
}


@Service
public class MyBeanService{
  //field autowiring
  @Autowired
  MyConstructorClass myConstructorClass;

  ....
}

Encampment

This doesn't even add much value. Instead of going through all this, just get your bean though BeanFactory in Configuration file and set your variables there. – Overlay

Answer 6

Most answers are fairly old, so it might have not been possible back then, but there actually is a solution that satisfies all the possible use-cases.

So right know the answers are:

• Not providing a real Spring component (the factory design)
• or does not fit every situation (using @Value you have to have the value in a configuration file somewhere)

The solution to solve those issues is to create the object manually using the ApplicationContext:

@Component
public class MyConstructorClass
{
    String var;

    public MyConstructorClass() {}
    public MyConstructorClass(String constrArg) {
        this.var = var;
    }
}

@Service
public class MyBeanService implements ApplicationContextAware
{
    private static ApplicationContext applicationContext;

    MyConstructorClass myConstructorClass;

    public MyBeanService()
    {
        // Creating the object manually
        MyConstructorClass myObject = new MyConstructorClass("hello world");
        // Initializing the object as a Spring component
        AutowireCapableBeanFactory factory = applicationContext.getAutowireCapableBeanFactory();
        factory.autowireBean(myObject);
        factory.initializeBean(myObject, myObject.getClass().getSimpleName());
    }

    @Override
    public void setApplicationContext(ApplicationContext context) throws BeansException {
        applicationContext = context;
    }
}

This is a cool solution because:

• It gives you access to all the Spring functionalities on your object (@Autowired obviously, but also @Async for example),
• You can use any source for your constructor arguments (configuration file, computed value, hard-coded value, ...),
• It only requires you to add a few lines of code without having to change anything.
• It can also be used to dynamically create a unknown number of instances of a Spring-managed class (I'm using it to create multiple asynchronous executors on the fly for example)

The only thing to keep in mind is that you have to have a constructor that takes no arguments (and that can be empty) in the class you want to instantiate (or an @Autowired constructor if you need it).

Regorge

whats the point of MyConstructorClass myConstructorClass;? You never use it? Did you to use myConstructorClass instead of myObject? – Andrewandrewes

@Andrewandrewes I honestly don't remember as it was a while back but yeah it might just be a mistake that I left or a variable that I was using before but ended up not needing. – Regorge

Just came across this thread and it's quite old, but people still look at it, so shall comment: this approach can't work correctly, since the applicationContext object is used in the c~tor, while it is being set only after the object is constructed (don't let static to mislead you). So this c~tor should fail on NPE in it's second line, shouldn't it? – Aviles

Answer 7

Another alternative, if you already have an instance of the object created and you want to add it as an @autowired dependency to initialize all the internal @autowired variables, could be the following:

@Autowired 
private AutowireCapableBeanFactory autowireCapableBeanFactory;

public void doStuff() {
   YourObject obj = new YourObject("Value X", "etc");
   autowireCapableBeanFactory.autowireBean(obj);
}

Neopythagoreanism

Answer 8

I like Zakaria's answer, but if you're in a project where your team doesn't want to use that approach, and you're stuck trying to construct something with a String, integer, float, or primative type from a property file into the constructor, then you can use Spring's @Value annotation on the parameter in the constructor.

For example, I had an issue where I was trying to pull a string property into my constructor for a class annotated with @Service. My approach works for @Service, but I think this approach should work with any spring java class, if it has an annotation (such as @Service, @Component, etc.) which indicate that Spring will be the one constructing instances of the class.

Let's say in some yaml file (or whatever configuration you're using), you have something like this:

some:
    custom:
        envProperty: "property-for-dev-environment"

and you've got a constructor:

@Service // I think this should work for @Component, or any annotation saying Spring is the one calling the constructor.
class MyClass {
...
    MyClass(String property){
    ...
    }
...
}

This won't run as Spring won't be able to find the string envProperty. So, this is one way you can get that value:

class MyDynamoTable
import org.springframework.beans.factory.annotation.Value;
...
    MyDynamoTable(@Value("${some.custom.envProperty}) String property){
    ...
    }
...

In the above constructor, Spring will call the class and know to use the String "property-for-dev-environment" pulled from my yaml configuration when calling it.

NOTE: this I believe @Value annotation is for strings, intergers, and I believe primative types. If you're trying to pass custom classes (beans), then approaches in answers defined above work.

Berthold

Answer 9

You need to use @Autowired and @Value. Refer this post for more information on this topic.

Nasya

The answer is there thought it's short. The answer in essence is to you '@Autowired' and '@Value'. I could have added it as a comment but it's a long time back and I'm not sure I had comment privileges... – Nasya