Javascript increment operation order of evaluation

Question

I know the what the postfix/prefix increment/decrement operators do. And in javascript, this seems to be no different.

While I can guess the outcome of this line easily:

var foo = 10; console.log(foo, ++foo, foo, foo++, foo); 
// output: 10 11 11 11 12

as ++ operators appear within separate expressions.

It gets a bit complicated as these operators appears within the same expression:

var foo = 10; console.log(foo, ++foo + foo++, foo);
// output[1]: 10 22 12
// Nothing unexpected assuming LTR evaluation

var foo = 10; console.log(foo, foo++ + ++foo, foo);
// output[2]: 10 22 12
// What? Ordering is now different but we have the same output.
// Maybe value of foo is evaluated lazily...

var foo = 10; console.log(foo, foo + ++foo, foo);
// output[3]: 10 21 11
// What?! So first 'foo' is evaluated before the increment?

and my question is, how does Javascript (V8 in this case, as I tested these in Chrome) end up evaluating the addition expression in 2nd and 3rd example differently?

Why does foo end up evaluating differently than foo++. Isn't postfix ++ supposed to increment after the expression and just evaluate to foo within expression?

Alvin

I believe the behavior you are describing shows that in javascript, addition is left associative. This means that the left expression in left_expression + right_expression is evaluated first. The increment operator is behaving in the way that you expect, I believe. – Mckean

Answer 1

Just look at:

foo++ + ++foo

Mentally rewrite it to:

foo++ →
    addition_lhs = foo  // addition_lhs == 10
    foo += 1            // foo == 11
++foo →
    foo += 1            // foo == 12
    addition_rhs = foo  // addition_rhs == 12

addition_lhs + addition_rhs == 10 + 12 == 22

And foo + ++foo:

foo →
    addition_lhs = foo  // addition_lhs == 10
++foo →
    foo += 1            // foo == 11
    addition_rhs = foo  // addition_rhs == 11

addition_lhs + addition_rhs == 10 + 11 == 21

So everything is evaluated left to right, including the incrementation.

The crucial rule to understand is that in JavaScript the whole left hand side (LHS) is executed, and the value memorized, before any operation gets done on the right hand side (RHS).

You can either confirm the evaluation order by reading the standard or just place a runtime error in your expression and look what happens:

alert(1) + alert(2) + (function () { throw Error(); })() + alert(3)

Phrygia

So I just had to know the increment happens immediately after the sub-expression (after a then after b in a + b), not full expression (after a + b). Makes sense. Thank you! – Alvin

Answer 2

Understand that when you use foo++ you're telling to the "compiler": after you push it to the stack, increment it. When you use ++foo you're telling the other way: increment it then push it to the stack. The ++ operator have preference over the +, since the "compiler" read the expression this way (foo++)+(++foo)

Jeramyjerba

Answer 3

var foo = 10; console.log(foo, ++foo + foo++, foo);

++foo + foo++
   11 + 11

The pre increment sets foo to 11 then adds it to foo again which is still 11, evaluating to 22 before foo is again incremented.

var foo = 10; console.log(foo, foo++ + ++foo, foo);

foo++ + ++foo
10    +    12

By the time we reach ++foo, the value has already incriminated from foo++

var foo = 10; console.log(foo, foo + ++foo, foo);

foo + ++foo
10  +   11

foo is incremented before we add it to foo, thus giving us 10 + 11

SUMMARY

Basically it all depends on what the current value of foo is when you add them together.

Klina